Fair for all guilds

"ImaSmakya;c-2077222" wrote:

"Waqui;c-2077216" wrote:

"ImaSmakya;c-2077189" wrote:

"Waqui;c-2077174" wrote:

"Kisermiester;c-2077155" wrote:
The game needs to be fair. And that means to individuals as well.

Again:
Raids are guild events - not individual events.

"Kisermiester;c-2077155" wrote:

You seem to think that if you have more people you should have more access. That's wrong!! I don't care if they did away with the tickets all together and had a time limit between the finish and start of a particular raid. Then the larger guilds will get through it faster and be starting the next one sooner. You still have the advantage.

What advantage? How fast you complete the raid has nothing to do with the amount of members in a guild, now that single players can complete the raids. Small guilds will do just as many raids as large guilds - and have the advantage of better rewards.

"Kisermiester;c-2077155" wrote:

Your way of thinking has driven off many players. We see this way is not working for many. Something needs to change in a fair way. And not in a way that one feels more entitled to access just because they have a larger group. That doesn't make any sense.

Then change it. Recruit 25 new members, merge with another small guild or leave your guild for a larger one.

“What advantage? How fast you complete the raid has nothing to do with the amount of members in a guild, now that single players can complete the raids.”

There are guilds the do not have a member that can solo a raid, there are guilds that still can’t even complete a high level Sith raid. The number of members definitely has a bearing on how fast some guilds complete a given raid.

Not leaning one way or the other on the fairness of the guild system, just clarifying some of the arguments.

Edit: took out one of my points as the context seemed wrong.

All it takes is one member, who can. It's got nothing to do with how many members a guild has.

But many young guilds still don’t have that person so it most definitely has something to do with the number of members.

Young guilds and incomplete guilds are two different things.

It's still has nothing to do with amount of members. It's about whether they have this one member who can solo raids. Either permanent member or mercenary.