Wai? I think not.We are in at 45/50, they are in at what I can assume is 42/50 as we are only allowed 21 per zone.Their gp is 138mill with 45/50 members. Out of those 42 profiles listed on swgoh.gg (42) 6 have revan maxed out. 5 have traya at 7* g10+We have 142mill gp (as of today) with 50/50. We have no trayas, no revans..... Hell it's a struggle to just get people with jtr for kittens sake.So that being said. CG, you failed, yet again.Tw matchmaking cannot alone be based on comparitive gp of the guild. Legendary characters, (revan, jtr, Luke etc) and trayas can easily sway the Ballance of any short comings in any tw.I now have a guild that I have to report to, saying pretty much "bend over" as we will yet again loose another tw despite our best efforts to place strong defenses. All they have to do is set revans teams in each of the front two zones and it's over. We have yet to beat any revan teams we have come up against since his release, in tw.Thanks again for completely demoralizing my guild and the 45 people who want a fair fight.

Seems to me your guild is not best built for TW. I see no problem with the match up. If you are 130 mill gp or greater, you should expect to see revan and traya on the other teams. If you do not have them it is your guild that is at fault.

I see it the other way. Your argument is invalid due to the fact that the reqs. for completing Hsith have been known for quite a while. The point is, the other guild stayed focused and were grinding out what was needed while yours was not. My guild is 100 mill GP and we complete Hsith regularly and have a few Revans/Traya. Why? Because we made it a goal and achieved it. There has been plenty of time to farm JTR. If the guild really wanted Traya, you would have it by now. NS are also a good counter to Traya. Seems like chasing the meta is what is keeping your guild from reaching your goals which I assume is Traya.

"Rhunne;c-1707027" wrote:Blaming the guild for being focused on preparation for heroic sith, rather then farming (spending) to get revan? How is it that we are unprepared? We have encountered many guilds (last tw for instance) where we where 130+ and they had no revans or trayas. That was a great tw and a close one. So your argument is invalid This right here kinda raises the point right there, if you are raid focused and they are TW focused, you are "not prepared". So his argument is valid.

The matchup we have is absolutely awful. They've wiped out our whole board and we haven't finished one section. CG you need to go back to the drawing board. This was the worst I've seen it.One thing that's crystal clear is guilds with ridiculous speed hide at lower gp but gain a huge unfair advantage in matchmaking. Perhaps matching off speed or other moded traits would create better parity.

My guild has decided collectively to essentially boycott tws. We will each place one team on defense so we count and leave it at that. We will take our two zetas and leave it. Why bother putting in any effort when cg/EA won't do the same

Matchmaking update? A lie? | EA Forums

32 Replies

Replies have been turned off for this discussion

Mookow23
7 years ago
Seems to me your guild is not best built for TW. I see no problem with the match up. If you are 130 mill gp or greater, you should expect to see revan and traya on the other teams. If you do not have them it is your guild that is at fault.
RiskRunner1
7 years ago
Blaming the guild for being focused on preparation for heroic sith, rather then farming (spending) to get revan? How is it that we are unprepared?

We have encountered many guilds (last tw for instance) where we where 130+ and they had no revans or trayas. That was a great tw and a close one. So your argument is invalid
Mookow23
7 years ago
I see it the other way. Your argument is invalid due to the fact that the reqs. for completing Hsith have been known for quite a while. The point is, the other guild stayed focused and were grinding out what was needed while yours was not. My guild is 100 mill GP and we complete Hsith regularly and have a few Revans/Traya. Why? Because we made it a goal and achieved it. There has been plenty of time to farm JTR. If the guild really wanted Traya, you would have it by now. NS are also a good counter to Traya. Seems like chasing the meta is what is keeping your guild from reaching your goals which I assume is Traya.
RiskRunner1
7 years ago
Traya really isnt the issue. She is easily countered. So in that regard I agree. I know we have people who have the teams to defeat traya. The other side is that traya is the hard counter to revan.

Realistically, the issue is how the matchmaking is done. To some extent cg should at least give us something on how it's calculated. The algorithm alone can't be based solely on gp, so what else is it?
tvsfrink
7 years ago
Be happy you have more GP. I can't remember the last time that happened to us. Not even close.

And they gave some hints last spring, but they can't reveal too much or people will exploit it.
Technopwns
7 years ago
Was it supposed to be an update? I thought I read it as, they will look into the upcoming matchmaking in TW, and not make changes yet. But still of course, guilds are getting put with bad match making.
N0oTry
7 years ago
WAI. I doubt they will ever make an algorithm that matches you based on the guilds spending grade...which is actually what you are asking for. Even if the algo accounted for Legs/Heros 6 Revans would make no difference since it's miniscule in number. But we know even a single Revan makes much difference.
RiskRunner1
7 years ago

Oh yeah, definitely Wai...
DuneSeaFarmer
7 years ago
Whale guilds are sleepers. They can have half your membership and pound the snot out of guilds with a lot more GP. New adjustments.. EPIC FAIL. Facing guilds with 3 to 4 GP per player, yeah we have a chance. Guess the rumors are true, whales complained and demanded easier matches.
NyKynoe
7 years ago
"Rhunne;c-1707027" wrote:
Blaming the guild for being focused on preparation for heroic sith, rather then farming (spending) to get revan? How is it that we are unprepared?

We have encountered many guilds (last tw for instance) where we where 130+ and they had no revans or trayas. That was a great tw and a close one. So your argument is invalid

This right here kinda raises the point right there, if you are raid focused and they are TW focused, you are "not prepared". So his argument is valid.