Rancor Ranking Spankings

"wrekincruw;c-1418643" wrote:
So everyone gets a trophy for showing up # NOWAY.

No, they get a trophy for solo'ing the raid. They have developed their toons too to be able to do that.

"wrekincruw;c-1418643" wrote:
What I'm saying is if I'm stronger have a more developed character base why is it that you guys think that I should have the same exact reward as someone who does not has not been playing longer has not more developed characters has a lower GP and does not finish the raid faster should get the same exact or better reward, there is no Sound Logic to that at all.

Time has never been a deciding factor when rankings are determined, so why you feel you deserve to be rewarded based on time is a puzzle to me, and apparently to everyone else as well.

Anyway, instead of your nonsensical suggestions, a better solution would be a new and much harder tier in the raid. Instead of starting threads with suggestions that have no chance of ever making it into the game, how 'bout you start a thread about that?

"wrekincruw;c-1418643" wrote:
And yes guildmates are supposed to help each other build the factors that if I'm able to finish the way it is helping everyone in general.

If others can solo the raid, your solos help no one.

"wrekincruw;c-1418643" wrote:
So they are getting something out of it should they get as much as me when I am doing more the answer is no

If you solo the raid and others solo the raid, you haven't done more.

"wrekincruw;c-1418643" wrote:
and I know a lot of you guys know each other and all in the same Guild which is why you are saying that because who in their right mind does all the work and let somebody else gets the credit?

If others solo it too, you haven't done all the work. You've all accomplished the exact same thing.

Btw, who are in the same guild? You seem to resort to conspiracy thinking now. How about acknowledging the possibility that you're wrong, and that's why everyone disagrees with you?

"wrekincruw;c-1418643" wrote:
In all honesty I would be fine when it comes down to it if we all got the same rewards but as far as someone getting a better reward no because that is a smack in the face it is saying no matter how hard you try it doesn't matter

Of course it matters. Everyone who can solo the raid have worked towards that goal, and their rewards will be better for it.

"wrekincruw;c-1418649" wrote:

"Naraic;c-1418184" wrote:
At the moment the rancour is too small a raid for big guilds. To be honest haat is too small a raid for big guilds.

Randomisation is ok. If you want to max your rewards go to a weaker guild where only you can solo.

That said it would be cool if you were ranked by the damage of the biggest single hit or something. Even better to get rid of the problem and move on to tier 8 raids.

If you perform 1st rate = you should get 1st place

If you perform first rate where everyone performs first rate you are merely average.

What gets me is that the "random" doesn't seem random at all. My guild has 12-18 that solo each raid yet there is 3 that are ALWAYS awarded the top 5. Same damage as the others that solo it. Sometimes finish quicker, sometimes longer but always better rewards than the rest of the guild. That's messed up. What is it that makes those 3 ALWAYS top 5 while there are a few of us that solo it, finish sooner, yet NEVER crack top 5. Get rid of that completely. If you solo it, get first place rewards. Make it like the guild activities payout. Is that really to much to ask?

Single toon registration chosen from a random faction, then ffa 24 hours later good luck tieing

"Demos1178;c-1437085" wrote:
What gets me is that the "random" doesn't seem random at all. My guild has 12-18 that solo each raid yet there is 3 that are ALWAYS awarded the top 5. Same damage as the others that solo it. Sometimes finish quicker, sometimes longer but always better rewards than the rest of the guild. That's messed up. What is it that makes those 3 ALWAYS top 5 while there are a few of us that solo it, finish sooner, yet NEVER crack top 5. Get rid of that completely. If you solo it, get first place rewards. Make it like the guild activities payout. Is that really to much to ask?

No it isnt too much! Only right

"Boofpoof;c-1438828" wrote:
I feel like I am speaking for the entire community by saying

1) I got my laugh for the day by reading the first post
2) That trying to convince the first part that he is just plain wrong would be the equivalent of trying to empty an ocean with a teaspoon
3) As has been said by others in this thread a guild is about lifting others up and not complaining that their work is nullified because others took longer to get to that level

* Gently lays microphone on floor * (because microphones lives matter)

I have to be in a guild to progress, does that mean i have to carry your types dead weight? No, its not alright, no sponge zone bro

"wrekincruw;c-1438830" wrote:

"Boofpoof;c-1438828" wrote:
I feel like I am speaking for the entire community by saying

1) I got my laugh for the day by reading the first post
2) That trying to convince the first part that he is just plain wrong would be the equivalent of trying to empty an ocean with a teaspoon
3) As has been said by others in this thread a guild is about lifting others up and not complaining that their work is nullified because others took longer to get to that level

* Gently lays microphone on floor * (because microphones lives matter)

I have to be in a guild to progress, does that mean i have to carry your types dead weight? No, its not alright, no sponge zone bro

Out of curiosity, what's your swgoh.gg page?

"t0neg0d;c-1438835" wrote:

"wrekincruw;c-1438830" wrote:

"Boofpoof;c-1438828" wrote:
I feel like I am speaking for the entire community by saying

1) I got my laugh for the day by reading the first post
2) That trying to convince the first part that he is just plain wrong would be the equivalent of trying to empty an ocean with a teaspoon
3) As has been said by others in this thread a guild is about lifting others up and not complaining that their work is nullified because others took longer to get to that level

* Gently lays microphone on floor * (because microphones lives matter)

I have to be in a guild to progress, does that mean i have to carry your types dead weight? No, its not alright, no sponge zone bro

Out of curiosity, what's your swgoh.gg page?

SWGOH page!? Dude, out of curiosity what does that have to do with anyyyything at all, just curious...

"Boofpoof;c-1438856" wrote:

"wrekincruw;c-1438830" wrote:

I have to be in a guild to progress, does that mean i have to carry your types dead weight? No, its not alright, no sponge zone bro

I am sorry for offending you. I wasnt aware that helping a member because:

A) They have less experience than ME
b) Their roster is not as fully developed as MINE
C) They lack the knowledge that I and I ALONE possess

Was a bad thing. Your sponge zone mentality and carrying dead weight mentality is intriguing. Please teach me the ways. Let me look upon your guild to see the dead weight you are unjustly and unfairly carrying. Perhaps too I can see the light and turn from the Dark Side.

Perhaps..
Your missing the point of this post it is about ME being rewarded justly for MY hardwork.

"wrekincruw;c-1438879" wrote:

"Boofpoof;c-1438856" wrote:

"wrekincruw;c-1438830" wrote:

I have to be in a guild to progress, does that mean i have to carry your types dead weight? No, its not alright, no sponge zone bro

I am sorry for offending you. I wasnt aware that helping a member because:

A) They have less experience than ME
b) Their roster is not as fully developed as MINE
C) They lack the knowledge that I and I ALONE possess

Was a bad thing. Your sponge zone mentality and carrying dead weight mentality is intriguing. Please teach me the ways. Let me look upon your guild to see the dead weight you are unjustly and unfairly carrying. Perhaps too I can see the light and turn from the Dark Side.

Perhaps..
Your missing the point of this post it is about ME being rewarded justly for MY hardwork.

Your hard work, which is to solo rancor. Which is now getting to be able to be done by many people. Might I point out that if you truly are this concerned about your rank for an original but now mid level raid, that you should find yourself a guild where you are the only person able to compete in heroic rancor. This will allow you to have first place every single raid, and the guild you join will actually like having you around because you are helping them to get resources faster and build their own rosters faster. Then, when they are able to challenge your score move on to another guild and repeat the process . This will ensure you consistently receive top rank and top prize for the rancor and the bonus is that you will help many fledgling guilds become stronger and progress faster.