Territory War balancing solution.

"BubbaFett;c-1627275" wrote:

"Kyno;c-1627263" wrote:

"BubbaFett;c-1627245" wrote:

"Kyno;c-1627243" wrote:

"BubbaFett;c-1627221" wrote:

"Kyno;c-1627210" wrote:
a major advantage of the current setup is that people who are not going to be around, dont hurt their guild by just sitting out. This is one of the best changes that has been added to this game mode.

there is also no reason to require 50 people. there are plenty of other ways to match without requiring 50 players.

Why should we get that "advantage"?...... The whole.point of tw is to pit two guilds against eachother in competition..... and having those guilds ",equal in Gp", would be exactly like professional sports where people compete in the same division..... There is nothing wrong with that......

If one guild is "strong" because they all have 7* cup, But they lose to a smarter guild that built quality gp, so be it.......

Every tw, there is a number of us screaming at you guys that guilds are sandbagging by leaving out members, yet you ignore it and post tripe.like this.....

There are a handful of things that make a guild good......

- members that focus and build good teams
- members who are active
- members that are focused on making the guild better, not just themselves....

Should these not be the guilds that are winning vs the guilds that are sandbagging to maximize their monthly zeta?

equal GP of the players involved, yes. not equal gp of the guild who could be there but didn't make it.

if we are talking about it being fair, it should be fair for everyone. this includes guilds who dont have all players show up.

you do know i am not a dev, right?

Kyno, I have never seen you be anything but fair.... Dev or non dev..... (And yes, you are not one)....

That being said, I don't agree with you on what is "fair"...... This is a guild event and , as such, requires guild participation...... if your guild isn't participating in a guild event, they deserve to lose....

Instead of encouraging an environment where guilds can maximize Zetas by strategically leaving members out, the devs should be encouraging max participation and building good toons...

They could match on so many things that have nothing to do with 50 players. this is unlike any other guild event we have, where your activity matters almost more than your GP, and not just activity, but activity at particular times out of your control.

why punish a growing guild, or a guild going through a rough patch, or a guild where someone ditches right before it opens? why punish a player (or thier guild) who will not be able to be on their phone for a whole day?

I'm not saying things dont need to be fixed, i'm just pointing out this particular aspect of TW, is good for the community. it needs to be fixed elsewhere. IMHO

Is punishing a "growing guild" worse than punishing one that took the effort to get establshed?..... Yes, they put the effort in, and they deserve the rewards for that effort......like I said, simply match guilds by GP and that goes away..... It isn't rocket surgery.... How about the system just matches straight up gp?......

the problem is, no its not that simple. 50 1.75M GP players wouldn't win against 30 3M GP players. its not about only GP.

Zeta counts, key toons (traya), average player GP, and G11/21 toon count need to all be considered to get a "fair match".