The Heroic AAT Raid...

I want to nerf heroic just to piss off whales now reading this.
All in favor of nerfing both difficulties now ;)

"Synfreak;756836" wrote:
It isn't up to you! They will take a look at how many guilds are completing heroic and they are going to make a decision based on that! Not based on comments from some people from the guilds that are completing it already lmao!!

Pretty much.
It's also evident whale guilds have more proportional representation in this forum then they have in game.

Heroic is solid.

Normal needs a slight health nerf, but I could live with it the way it is if:

Add a lower tier so it doesn't take lower guilds more then a 7-10 days.But only by lowering health to keep it a challenge.

"myea8017;754645" wrote:
We finished it on 52 minutes today. Let's leave the herioc alone.

Does that not mean that it is too easy, so quadruple the health?

"tRRRey;756839" wrote:

"GeorgeRules;756413" wrote:
Leave heroic alone but add the same rewards to t6. Or make heroic more accessible. The former makes sense to me. Normal mode and hard mode... Both should be rewarding. Especially as normal mode can take some time.

If you're suggesting normal mode should award Kenobi shards or equal amounts of gear as heroic, I have to disagree. Heroic has to be more rewarding than normal because it's evidently more difficult

I disagree, I think if you have the right squads it is easy to do the required 1 mil of damage on auto. In fact, I'd say the fact normal takes longer to complete would say that people should be getting more rewards for that than a 1 hour heroic effort. The difference is squads and mods, not effort.

ive been saying this for since for 2 weeks

if anything buff it back up a little

"GeorgeRules;757069" wrote:

"tRRRey;756839" wrote:

"GeorgeRules;756413" wrote:
Leave heroic alone but add the same rewards to t6. Or make heroic more accessible. The former makes sense to me. Normal mode and hard mode... Both should be rewarding. Especially as normal mode can take some time.

If you're suggesting normal mode should award Kenobi shards or equal amounts of gear as heroic, I have to disagree. Heroic has to be more rewarding than normal because it's evidently more difficult

I disagree, I think if you have the right squads it is easy to do the required 1 mil of damage on auto. In fact, I'd say the fact normal takes longer to complete would say that people should be getting more rewards for that than a 1 hour heroic effort. The difference is squads and mods, not effort.

By your logic normal is somehow harder to complete than heroic, so why aren't more guilds switching over to heroic? Because there's no risk of failure when you start normal, and a lot of people don't have the right squads. If they did you wouldn't see the forums drowning in complaints about normal mode. The only problem with normal is the health values, everything besides that makes is much easier than heroic and thus it should never give the same rewards as heroic. If rewards were based on time needed for completion it would encourage even more guilds to draw out their normal raids.

Another "I can do it, so it's fine/It's insane, please nerf" topic.

AAT is not about you, folks. Here some different questions:

1. How many people did Rancor at the first week and how many did AAT?

2. If I start to play today, how long it takes to do heroic AAT?

3. People are starting to quit? How many?

4. If a lot of people quit, EA will continue support this game?

Someone will say "only whales matters to EA". I don't think so. It's not fun be a whale if everybody is. The ocean needs little tiny fishs too to be fun.

+1

Phase 1 still 85% left to go. Started the raid 2 days after it opened only because it has a cap. A lower Tier would be appreciated.

Look, i agree the heroic is fine as is
its just that it has great requirements (at least my roster depth) which most guilds don't have. not even mine does, sure once most are lvl 85 and have more g11 chars we will crush it
but for most of the community that is at least 5-6 months away

and then there is the fact that some guilds consolidated their whales and now they find that it's getting too easy; here is your solution to make it harder, bring some of your weak members in to the heroic tiers, get them to do heroics, cycle the whales back to the weak guilds so that all the sub guild are doing heroic.