Should I make these two supernatural? If so, which occults?

Make him a witch, and her a vampire.

I think she has cute fairy face,he gives me the witchy/warlock vibe.So Annabeth should be an adorable fairy of some type even a dark gothic fairy would be sweet if they hook up cause Carson can be the evil warlock that fell in love with her.Plus that will be 2 different powers to use around the house.

Hi :)

Go for it.

I voted one of each - witch and mortal, because I think they lack the "mean beauty" and vampire aura about them. I would have said fairies - they both look tender and pixie like! :)

Fairies is a good idea, Make him a witch and her a fairy

I say have them both be mortals, but that's just what I would do since I don't really like supernaturals.

Vampires are just cool, so I choose them :)

It wasnt one of your listed options, but these are sims you used to play and recreated right? So how about ghosts? Since the originals would have probably passed on by this point.

Would be nice with some feedback to know what you've decided...