Hmm maybe something like
Brightpoint? I'll add to this if I find anything else, but I've played in Brightpoint and it's very quaint and it definitely reminds me of New England (though I'm from the opposite side of the country and have never been to NE :p ). It's very small, so whether that is a drawback or not depends on how you view it. Also, all houses come unfurnished. The rabbit holes are quite cute because they're in the basement, allowing the creator to make buildings that fit the aesthetic of the world. The same creator has more worlds if you end up liking Brightpoint.