I tested this: new folder, made one sim, moved them to lot Honeydew Fields in Britechester, enrolled in university, joined soccer team, levelled up to Starter, when they can play soccer games. Played one game 10 times over, by saving and reloading it. The first one they were at Foxbury commons when soccer practice started; the other times they went there from home lot. 3/10 games they came home early, ca at 8pm, before the set time of 6 pm-9 pm; and directly after I had made a choice presented at the Soccer Game Moment pop-up screen. I always picked the top choice.
When they were sent home early, there were no notification on winning/losing the game, as with the other times. Also coinciding was the moodlet Soccer Injury; which the sim did not have the times they stayed till 9 pm, and won/lost the game.
@ashleighelissa Did your sim also have the Soccer Injury moodlet all the times they were sent home early? Did you get any notifications on winning/losing the game?
Have you never experienced a time when they played till 9 pm (the time the soccer is scheduled to end)?