Cult or Commune challenge

*I was initially following the exact rules of the challenge but have tweaked it more to make a better storyline, so everything may not comply with rules*

Finally it was time to explore! Being stuck in Newcrest was certainly not in Tatum's best interest (and the camp's, you could say). Branching out seemed like a great opportunity to harvest more plants, catch new creatures, and look for new recruits. On deciding to pick a lot in Willow Creek, all four of them were assigned different roles, but the main goal was to breed frogs. Frog breeding was a niche market that Tatum thought would be perfect for them all. Very simple and all you needed was to start with two frogs and proceed from there. Unfortunately frogs do not want to breed all day and so this seemed a tedious process even though there were four of them to keep an eye.

https://i.imgur.com/WTjLuNQ.png

After they had done all they could, Don and Brant were escorted home by a mysterious figure... Tatum totally oblivious would have no clue who Brant would be sneaking off to see now. Zoe fished for hours and hours, losing track of time completely! Her needs unbothered by the time she spent out fishing Rainbowfish. Soon Tatum had decided to go home for some sleep, trusting Zoe to make it home with all the money.

https://i.imgur.com/4a3P8dM.png

Trust? Trust!? What was happening to Tatum?