I don't think I'd want consequences On/Off as a whole. What if I disagree with a particular consequence? What if my state/county/country has different consequences for a certain thing than California, USA? There are already places in Parenthood where even with a parent with Parenting 10 who can see all the options and - yes, consequences to a particular parenting problem, I disagree with all the options. Either because the Sim I'm playing wouldn't pick one of them, or because I personally parent differently than the game is designed for in that particular instance. I'm not sure I'd enjoy that problem writ large across the whole game.
That said, I would like consequences for some things, and for my criminal sims to occasionally spend the night in lock up, or my teenagers to get suspended or detention for skivvying off of school too often, or stuff like that.
So if the Consequences toggle wasn't one toggle, but say a handful - Health, criminal, school, social ... maybe Occult - that could be individually turned on or off, then maybe.
