Forum Discussion

XDomina's avatar
XDomina
Seasoned Scout
2 months ago
Solved

Melodic Voice is Broken

With the last update (Patch 1.116, July 1st), many of the lines for the Melodic Voice have been changed to a different one, but not nearly close to all. So the characters keep changing between voices all the time, which is inconsistent, distracting, and overall bad for our gameplay experience.

Besides, the Melodic Voice as we know it has been with us for over ten years now, and not only have many of us grown used to it, it is an intrinsic part of the personality to many of our beloved characters. I for one don't want to see it retroactively changed, much less arbitrarily or carelessly.

We understand that Voice Actors are human beings, and that a lot can happen in a decade. With the game still in active development, it is understandable that there might be a need for more lines to be added.

But to replace lines that have already existed with us for a long time, whilst failing to add any new contexts, interaction options or new dialogues, whilst also not fully replacing all the voice over lines but to keep it in an inconsistent hybrid state, is simply detrimental to us users, and objectively undesirable.

Please revert these changes as soon as possible, and let's find a better solution for the future regarding this, or a more satisfactory compromise if one needs to be reached.

  • Hey all, 

    I've moved this thread out of the Bug Reports section as it turns out that this was not a bug at all, but rather the result of the original Melodic voice actor leaving the cast early last year. 

    While this may have been an intentional change and not a bug, your feedback here has been noted and flagged to the appropriate teams on our side. While I can't promise that anything will come of it, Maxis are now aware of this thread and your concerns. 

    Thanks for noticing these details, it's one of the things that makes me appreciate this community so much. 

22 Replies

  • I too am very disappointed in the change. I would prefer if both voices could stay in the game as long as the previous Melodic voice came back. As an American black woman the previous Melodic voice has always been the closest to my real voice and I feel like I’ve now lost a connection to this game :/

  • CHE_999_Berlin's avatar
    CHE_999_Berlin
    Seasoned Rookie
    2 months ago

    Iamoz96 mentioned it's the same voice actress and I had that feeling too. However, it sounds so different that you hardly can tell.
    So, I guess they decided to redo all phrases, little by little? Ah, it will take a while for me to cope with it 😄. Probably also because the voice acting is so important for this game and honestly, I love it. Particularly the voice actors did a fantastic job. 

    What I was always wondering: Over all these years, plenty of new DLCs came out and most of them got new phrases. I mean, most of them are based on DLCs from earlier Sims games, so it was kinda clear what's going to come, or at least what *could* come. So, how much voice acting have they done in advance to use it in later packs?

  • XDomina's avatar
    XDomina
    Seasoned Scout
    2 months ago

    Not a bug, a "feature". They've (arbitrarily) replaced the lines (for IMO, no good reason). #BringMelodicVoiceBack #JusticeForFemaleVoice3

    I joke but I'm actually pretty sad with this change. It's like they took away a bunch of my 10+ year old beloved characters overnight :(

  • T0kyo679's avatar
    T0kyo679
    New Novice
    2 months ago

    Is this a bug of some sort? This sim has the same Melodic voice option. But for some reason after the update came out, it sounds different. Every other voice sounds the same.

  • InfiniteVerve's avatar
    InfiniteVerve
    Seasoned Ace
    2 months ago

    Did something happen (bug?) to the melodic voice? It's changed.

  • MagesticalMyst's avatar
    MagesticalMyst
    Seasoned Novice
    2 months ago

    It Would be a different story if the voice actress had died. because then that would likely Require a new voice when adding new dialogues...but that itself is a risky thing because as you say, that is changing a Voice we have known for TEN Plus Years

  • XDomina's avatar
    XDomina
    Seasoned Scout
    2 months ago

    YES! I HATE IT! Please EA, revert it back! Completely unnecessary, none of the other voices were changed, why on earth did they "need" to change this, no one asked for it. I wish I knew this had happened before updating. I would have never updated my game again, it completely ruins a third of my female population, as now every 30 seconds they turn into a completely different person. It's bad.

    Like iamoz96​ said, I'm completely fine with them adding new lines, it is obviously necessary as the game is still in development. I get it, no one minds that. But to change voice lines we've grown used and have been using for 10 years, especially when it's so different, is a terrible decision. It may seem trivial to them, but it really is not, this kind of stuff completely puts me off from wanting to play the game.

  • pvrescue1's avatar
    pvrescue1
    New Hotshot
    2 months ago

    Interesting. Wish I could add more, but I haven't updated my game to the latest patch yet (probably won't until critical issues get fixed), and there don't appear to be any clips of the updated voice lines either... for now.

  • iamoz96's avatar
    iamoz96
    Rising Ace
    2 months ago

    Yes, they did re-do the melodic voice with the same voice actor. Honestly not a fan of it since it does sound scratchy and irritating to listen to like you said. I'm okay with them adding new phrases but not replacing all of the original voice acting after 10 years of this game. 

    (I'm on PC)

  • Am I the only one that is almost shocked by the new voice acting for the female "melodic" (actually rather scratchy & cheeky) voice? I noticed some new phrases in the business & hobbies pack, but with PS5 patch 2.14 (I think), it's also used for "standard free will chatting" i.e. without particular social interactions. The voice sounds really different and to hear it mixed with the one you got used to is really irritating.

    Someone got details? Is it even the same voice actor? Do they plan to progress to replace it completely?

About The Sims 4 Feedback

Share your feedback around The Sims 4 with the community.3,706 PostsLatest Activity: 3 minutes ago