Rise And Shine fable

How do I complete the Rise and Shine fable? It says ask sims about their fairy beliefs, and it was going fine until now. It says they have to be Innisgreen locals and non occult, but there isn’t 8 non occult sims in Innisgreen. I’ve tried asking sims who don’t live in Innisgreen but there’s no option to ask about their fairy beliefs. And the last time I asked someone their fairy beliefs it for some reason didn’t count towards the quest? Should I just make a bunch of new sims and move them to Innisgreen so I can ask them and complete this or will that not work? There’s also no option to ask the sims I already asked again.