I play both. Unlike some people I love ALL animals (real and pixel) but the dogs in Sims4 is really pushing my buttons. I'm so tired of them running in a bush every half a second and always coming out bit or sprayed. Soon as I bathe him or get him treated he's right back to it. I had to take the party bush out of my Sims' yards because of this stupid obsession. I don't know if it's like that for everyone, but it's that way for me and frankly it's tiresome. I can't even take the dog to the Bluffs because of those bushes and his unhealthy need to go in them. I'm also tired of his constant whining. He has friendly, hunter, and smart traits, but somehow he suddenly forgot he's housebroke. My Sim takes him walking and soon as they get home he starts whining to go back out. I send him hunting and he enjoys that, but when he comes home he whines. Gawd...reminds me of my ex whine whine whine haha...I'm almost wanting to adopt him out soon because of this. If I wanted something so demanding I would have had a child.