Forum Discussion

SimsLovinLycan's avatar
6 years ago

Eco Lifestyle Gameplay Trailer Reviews Thread.

Alright, so the second "Eco Lifestyle" trailer has just dropped. On this thread, you can leave a review of the trailer, just keep your critique as civil and constructive as possible (none of that "eco agenda conspiracy" stuff, please...no matter how cringe you thought the trailer was).


To me, this trailer was just as shallow as the reveal trailer. Again, it felt more like an environmentalist PSA that would run during a children's cartoon block back in the 90's than anything Sims related. It was just too...soft and gentle. The narrator's voice was too cute and girlish, adding to the kids' PSA vibe, and the fact that she was mostly rattling off the same generic environmental clean-up checklist that we've been told since 1987 will magically clean all the pollution away and make Mother Earth happy doesn't help. Strip the pack logos off and put the logos of the EPA and a couple of other organizations dedicated to cleaning up our planet and keeping it that way there instead, and you wouldn't even know it's a game ad. That's how much of a schmaltzy PSA this trailer is...and, by the looks of it, this pack.

Cleaning up and maintaining our environment is important, but PSA environmentalism is too shallow and overly simplistic to deal with the challenges we face and making a whole EP dedicated to it isn't helping anyone. Environmentalism isn't just sticking some wind turbines and solar panels on your house, doing your three R's (reduce, reuse, recycle), planting some trees, and calling it a day. We have to FIGHT for our environment because large corporations and the wealthy people who run them would rather let the Earth go to pot in order to preserve their profit margins than be environmentally responsible...even if that means slightly lower profits and slower growth. A community action board is NOTHING compared to pulling your community together to vote in and lobby politicians who will support Earth-friendly policies and create positive incentives (not just tax penalties and fines for polluting, but tax breaks and government grants to encourage companies to operate in a more environmentally friendly manner) to stop polluting. We need BIG action to clean up our world and keep it clean, not just some PSA, armchair environmentalism that does very little compared to the massive damage that irresponsible corporations do on a daily basis.

But, that tougher environmentalism is not represented here. It's just the same stuff we've been spoon-fed in PSA's since the 1980's. In 2020, we are beyond the point where that sort of armchair environmentalism looks anywhere near hopeful. It's a daydream, a fantasy, compared to what we really must hunker down and do since we let things slip so badly. This trailer looks childish and about 25 or 30 years out of date, and by extension, so does the EP. That's a real shame. EA's marketing team really needs to do better with this one, because this is one of the most poorly-conceived game trailers I have ever seen in my entire life.

27 Replies

  • "Renato10;c-17506961" wrote:
    I hate how they are marketing The Sims nowadays. They are talking to us like if we are 2 years old kids. Aren't they proud of the long time simmers anymore?


    No, I'm afraid they aren't. I think the 20th anniversary fiasco showed that quite clearly. The only Simmers that matter to them these days are the young kids they're so painfully trying to appeal to. Never mind the fact that it's us older, long-time Simmers that have the disposable cash to spend on their product.
  • "crocobaura;c-17507206" wrote:
    "alanmichael1;c-17507203" wrote:
    I liked the ladder animation, the insect farm and the vertical gardens and I will use the jacket of the main female character for my guys. The rest looked quite bad, especially the giant machines. I hope we don't need another special crafts table for the candles which then would stand in a 22 km long row besides the normal crafts table, the spooky ct, the flower ct, the archeology ct, the robotic ct, the weather station and the SV spy station.


    The candle craft station is actually made up of TWO objects, a desk and a wax barrel, it takes up 3 tiles. :joy:


    Why am I not surprised ?
  • At least this time they’re being upfront about selling actual trash.
  • ChadSims2's avatar
    ChadSims2
    Seasoned Rookie
    6 years ago
    "babajayne;c-17507529" wrote:
    At least this time they’re being upfront about selling actual trash.

    The only thing this pack is missing is a dumpster fire which would truly complete it.
  • I'm hoping the livestream shows more. I used to really enjoy going to the dump in Sims 3 (or was it Sims 2? I've been playing since the beginning) to scavenge for parts, etc. I'm happy that off-the-grid will finally be usable. The build/buy and new craftables look good. My real complaint is the narration. Good grief, can you get any more cringey or preachy? That part was a fail. Watch it without sound and pause to look at the stuff. Much more watchable. I've pre-ordered and am looking forward to the pack.
  • I thought both trailers were the same too. But I am getting story ideas of trying the death by flies on this Knox guy. It's a hard Knox life on him. ;)
  • "QuillWriter;c-17507235" wrote:
    "Renato10;c-17506961" wrote:
    I hate how they are marketing The Sims nowadays. They are talking to us like if we are 2 years old kids. Aren't they proud of the long time simmers anymore?


    No, I'm afraid they aren't. I think the 20th anniversary fiasco showed that quite clearly. The only Simmers that matter to them these days are the young kids they're so painfully trying to appeal to. Never mind the fact that it's us older, long-time Simmers that have the disposable cash to spend on their product.


    I keep hearing people say this but what about all the parents who buys games for their kids? When I was little my dad use to buy me whatever game I asked for. And we were far from being rich.
    My sister spends atleast 30 dollars a week buying robux for her kid. And then i saw all these other kids in roblox wearing and using things that they could only have if they spent mucho money on robux. And of course their parents brought it for them.

    Doesn't seem so unreasonable to market it to kids. Though I'm not saying it's right to leave loyal fans in the dust or anything. I just think it's normal for a business to constantly aim for the new generation.

About The Sims 4 General Discussion

Join lively discussions, share tips, and exchange experiences on Sims 4 Expansion Packs, Game Packs, Stuff Packs & Kits.33,809 PostsLatest Activity: 5 minutes ago