Gah. But I want all of them.
Supernatural and Farming are on par, especially if farming has horses. Tropical Vacation is just slightly behind those on my list of wants.
As for why:
I feel like Supernatural has more to play with, I can use it again and again for different supernaturals, and I'm holding out hope for mermaids. Farming is interesting, but only really useful for one or two sims, unless it comes with horses. Tropical Vacation seems like the obvious vacation spot that I'm surprised isn't already a thing, but I don't vacation sims that often anyway.
