Well I will try and keep this short but from ones I've played with
1.Love After Break Up
- I liked this one the best but the fact that you can ony have those 2 sims in household and you have to make new household and they can be related to absolutely no one...
makes it one time thing for me.
well that and the fact that ive played all the romance stuff in game thousand times and we still don't have any new romance gameplay to really make it exciting
2. Too Many Toddlers
- Again the limitations above +why not have more than 3 toddlers if you want to and why not raise all their toddler skills to max instead if you trying to feel like its challenge thing
3.Perfectly well rounded
- still similar thoughts as above but additional irritations like why just 3 skills though
tbh I think it would have been more fun to reach high level in 10 skills or something
it gets boring really fast when you don't have any other sims in your household or have anything to do other than watch your sim do same animations over and over (don't start me on herbalism man)
and yet it feels weird to focus on other skills when your challenge is just 3 skills
also in regards to aspirations... bugs. unable to complete milestones cause bugs was very irritating especially as its timed scenario and all so i can't even pretend it would have worked nicely for someone using that aspiration
+ limited time = bad time.
nothing let me repeat nothing should be limited time, ever. and thats just the tea.
4. Surviving the holidays
well for one its extremely similar to the first one, and yes i do quite like romancing with enemies but again...lacking gameplay on that front makes it kinda meh you'll just find way to make sims flirty and wee there you go same old same old
also I would have liked game to match the season so it would be actually holidays in the game when you start this scenario because now I am stuck playing half of the fall before i can even get to the actual holiday and im wondering if i should just have winterfest in autumn to be done with it (probably not but still...)
oh and i would have liked at least one of the goals to be really more about holiday itself
aaand why is it just holiday of two come on family time and all
oh and yeah reward is kinda meh but then again i dont really want to have to unlock cool stuff by doing these scenarios either cause itd just be so annoying when you want the reward but don't want to play scenario for it and if it was for specific save or household having to do it multiple times just to use the object is sigh.
oh and as for making money which i didn't start: the problem really is that such amount of money takes a loooong time so like if you want to do any other scenarios you can't do that simultaneously and then like you really end up picking other scenarios over it
sure its probably useful for people playing rags to riches minus other scenarios though