Pros: The world is absolutely stunning and the build items are too. It's reignited by interest in building because we can make a different kind of lot. Beach houses or huts. Lends really well to living of the land or off the grid. Careers are more fleshed out than we're used too. I'm really enjoying being able to have part time jobs and take on odd jobs. Cas items aren't too bad either. I love mermaids because i'm an occult girl through and through so I will take anything I can get.
Cons: The world is small and the community lots are lacking but this can be fixed with some builds of my own. No special animation when turning into a mermaid just a little back flip in the water. No vacation spots but again I can mod this if I wanted too. No supernatural skin tones for memaids.
Overall i'm finding the pack really enjoyable. It brings another aspect to gameplay for me and is up there with Seasons for me. I didn't expect to enjoy it as much as I am. I wish the world was bigger but it runs really well on my laptop so I can't complain really. I can't lie, I miss hotels of some description. It would have been cool to have atleast one lot to be a hotel so it could be used as a vacation world if we want too.