Re: Can't Use DLC from Separate Discs

If you have 2 disk versions of the base game each with a different expansion (Island living or City living) you will never be able to access both expansions together.

If order to be able to have both, you would need to download the version you want to add and always use that same disk when playing.

For example, you can insert your City living disk.  Once loaded on the load screen you can purchase and download the Island Expansion.

You will now how BOTH expansions available when playing with your CITY LIVING disk.

If you were to insert your Island Living disk - that is all you would see.

Unfortunately, your friend should have just gifted you a Gift card to buy the online version of the games - because you cannot use them together now.