@loafieh
Thanks for the screenshot, really helpful. None of those saves are going to load because of the extra digits. Saves should be named Save_ and then eight numbers/letters then .save. You have a space then one or two additional numbers indicating multiple copies of the same file. For example:
Save_00000002 7.save
should be:
Save_00000002.save
Have you checked your internal storage? Maybe it's getting full and pushing all saves to the cloud which is creating copies - https://answers.ea.com/t5/Technical-Issues-Mac/READ-FIRST-Saves-CC-Mods-or-Library-items-disappeared/m-p/10242133#M45493