Accidentally Saved Over One of My Game Files

@jpkarlsen Thank you for the suggestion. I did try those options, but the old game is gone. I was actually thinking about this more last night and I'm no longer sure I saved over the game file. If I had saved over my "Hard Mode" game with the "Original Game" game, then the two "Original Game" game files I have in my load screen should have similar date+time files in the Restore Game option, but they don't. Instead, one of them is the one I was using the day I lost the other file - they're all from various times on the same date. The other file, however, will only let me recover saves from September 2020, but I know I've used that game since then. The same dats are in my Saves folder in the automatically created backups. There don't appear to be any backups of the "Hard Mode" file. It's like the game never existed and somehow the automatic backup system pulled an old backup file and used that instead of my "Hard Mode" game.