Sous Judgmental making me GROUCHY!

My Sim is at the "Make a Quiche for the Grouch" portion of the Sous Judgmental quest. The problem is, my Sim can't access the Quiche to cook it. The instructions state it's unlocked at level 4 of the cooking hobby, I have cooked until my Sim has reached what the Sim tracker says level 6! What am I missing? What am I doing wrong? I've been cooking for WEEKS!!!! I'M FRUSTRATED!!