This policy is flawed, i had to rescind it.If someone is dropping naughty on YOU, that's one more bow that you got, which you otherwise wouldn't get. With only 5 presents to drop per day, your neighbors could drop all of them on someone else. Then you get no bows. You can't compare 1 vs 15, its 1 vs 0!So id rather have 1-5 naughty bows from them, than no bows. Of course, you shouldn't give your own presents to them if you can't trust they'll be nice. That would be a loss for you. But single extras from naughties shouldn't be denied, that's foolish.

Nope, if they send me a lot of naughty gifts I send them a nice gift to thank them for the gifts I would not of gotten other wise.

I'm with 4junk3000; I am not getting loads of gifts, just a couple a day, so if they drop me a Naughty and I gain one Bow, I'll take it. I also do not return a gift back at them. I just spread my 5 over people that have dropped a Nice in the past on me.

I like my neighbors and wont drop them for being naughty. :D OP if you're basing your naughty list on the leader board then keep in mind that some player have feeder towns.

I don't drop my naughty neighbours out, it is their legitimate choice, I just put them at the end of my long delivery list.Neighbours being naughty bring a bit of a risk in a game. Without surprises, even if they are disappointing, would be boring. If I knew that I would get only nice presents they wouldn't be so precious and exciting. It would be just a routine.

4junk3000 wrote:This policy is flawed, i had to rescind it.If someone is dropping naughty on YOU, that's one more bow that you got, which you otherwise wouldn't get. With only 5 presents to drop per day, your neighbors could drop all of them on someone else. Then you get no bows. You can't compare 1 vs 15, its 1 vs 0!So id rather have 1-5 naughty bows from them, than no bows. Of course, you shouldn't give your own presents to them if you can't trust they'll be nice. That would be a loss for you. But single extras from naughties shouldn't be denied, that's foolish.I must disagree with you, when I'm dropping presents I come across towns where I can't drop. If one of those is a "naughty" box this means my neighbour has gained 1 from that box but lost 15 from me. I'm dropping naughty neighbours as I don't want their 1 bow blocking a place for a nice 15 bows.

Have you also been dumping your naughty "friends?"

stephtog
9 years ago
I can't afford to drop naughty neighbours, I'm too near the end of the alphabet!!
chaffey1973
9 years ago
There is a flaw with the idea that if you get 1 bow that's one more than 0. There is a limit to how many presents can be dropped on you in a day. Wouldn't you rather have nice friends who drop you 15?

I have too many friends and neighbor visits are tiring in an event. You only get Santa hats from viewing a few of them. so, i'm dropping my naughty neighbors. They can always find new friends. It's a called a friend list. Not an enemy list. Your friends shouldn't be taking points from you.
lynnmckenz82
9 years ago
Not at this time. I'm not giving them any presents, though. I save those for the nice folks. Seems to be working well enough as a strategy so far.
perkilusen
9 years ago
amazonprimechic wrote:
OP if you're basing your naughty list on the leader board then keep in mind that some player have feeder towns.

This. I was curious about the nice/naughty thing so I left naughty presents in my other town.

That sounds wrong.
vibra5
New Rookie
9 years ago
in a first lap I decided to go in alphabetical order, but some are full and I could not leave anything

when I finish the first lap then I'll look who deserves a second gift but we will be the risk of not being able to leave one who always full when you go, I apologize to those who remain excluded

I apologize with those who received a bad gift, I thought we would win by guessing what was in the gift as heads or tails...

Now I'll be good I hope not to forget anyone, but I can not make a list of those who have already rewarded and who was full ....
chris60119
9 years ago
Nope, but I will drop my neighbors that aren't playing after Act 1. I figure thats long enough time for them to update.
Shirtless_Willi
9 years ago
izabellatrix wrote:
I'm not deleting them, but I am hiding them.

That's what I've been doing. I think completely removing a neighbor for picking Naughty is a bit much, but since we have so few presents to give out hiding naughty neighbors is good enough.
thejanik3
9 years ago
I don't drop naughty friends... I only drop my own presents with people that have a 100% nice rating and they always give them to me back. We didn't decide to do this but it has been working this way naturally. If someone drops me a present and they choose naughty, well, that's still one more bow than I had before. I have a 100% nice rating so a lot of people take advantage of me by dropping naughty presents in my town so they can benefit. Good for them! However, I think some people are trying to sabotage me because I sometimes find presents hidden behind buildings that aren't anywhere near my landing zone. It seems like they are trying to hide presents in my town so that other people can't drop their's in my town :evil:
SquirrelLadd
9 years ago
No I keep all my friends....even keep them for a couple of months when they appear to have stopped playing before I finally delete them.
Like other have said, I appreciate getting any presents and 1 bow is better than none :-)
I've tried to keep a list of people who leave them but it's hard to return to everyone with only 5 per day.
I also think some neighbours dont come to this forum....wow, dont think my game would be anywhere near as good without all the fantastic help here.....and maybe dont realise the impact of naughty/nice etc.
I just save my presents to drop on nice friends :-)
jax16389
9 years ago
I like my neighbors and wont drop them for being naughty. I've had most of the same neighbors since I started playing, not gonna get rid of them now. :D