Now there is a non-biased evaluation. Some people moan and cry about what they don't like here and then come up with a new way to perpetuate it.

She was kind enough to do this in the other forum, received quite a bit of backlash from a number of users, people not asking to be graded. She even responded to the posts there, so she saw the backlash, but obviously has decided it means nothing and wants to troll this board to try to get people to respond in the same. If I were anyone I would ignore her grades and get on. Someone seems to like drama, enjoy

I know this is just your opinion, but you really don't want to get people upset if their grade was low.

I don't want to be graded as I've still got a ton to do. I just want to see some amazing towns. Almost all of my friends have put little to no effort into their town planning and layout.

There are much better ways to do something like this, if you want to be inclusive and keep people from getting upset; let people vote on judges, establish and post the criteria/grading system, allow people to submit their towns on their own so people are not upset (based on my assumption from reading other posts that many did not ask to be graded.) Keep grades private and let people post themselves if they want to.Apologies if any of this was done and I'm unaware of it, just going by what I see in this thread.

Jarci's Springfield Grades | EA Forums

missyolga
12 years ago
melodyhodge wrote:
Lol what makes me laugh is that people really think there are a panel of judges haha. This is just some girl, bored in her room. People are sheep and they will follow.

jarci1 wrote:
Updated 2013-03-01 (added 35 people)
Updated 2013-02-26 (added 40 people)

Our judges have deliberated and provided up-to-date grades of various top Springfields in the community. If you would like to see how you stack up against the world's best just add jarci1 in-game.

Yes, because, WHO are those judges she is telling about?
Other players?

Not seems fair to me!

Jarci, are you on my neighbourslist?
melodyhodge
12 years ago
missyolga wrote:
melodyhodge wrote:
Lol what makes me laugh is that people really think there are a panel of judges haha. This is just some girl, bored in her room. People are sheep and they will follow.

jarci1 wrote:
Updated 2013-03-01 (added 35 people)
Updated 2013-02-26 (added 40 people)

Our judges have deliberated and provided up-to-date grades of various top Springfields in the community. If you would like to see how you stack up against the world's best just add jarci1 in-game.

Yes, because, WHO are those judges she is telling about?
Other players?

Not seems fair to me!

Jarci, are you on my neighbourslist?

I have come to the conclusion that she is crazy.
NeoSEC28
12 years ago
missyolga wrote:
Jarci, are you on my neighbourslist?

Sorry Missy couldnt help say this but.......... Surely you know whos on your friends list? :lol:
missyolga
12 years ago
NeoSEC28 wrote:
missyolga wrote:
Jarci, are you on my neighbourslist?

Sorry Missy couldnt help say this but.......... Surely you know whos on your friends list? :lol:

I think hahaha, its way tooo big, but when people have different names for the game, who can follow then :x :evil: ,

And are you sure your still on it :lol: :lol: as I seems to forget names when I am deleting :mrgreen: 8)
NeoSEC28
12 years ago
missyolga wrote:
NeoSEC28 wrote:
missyolga wrote:
Jarci, are you on my neighbourslist?

Sorry Missy couldnt help say this but.......... Surely you know whos on your friends list? :lol:

I think hahaha, its way tooo big, but when people have different names for the game, who can follow then :x :evil: ,

And are you sure your still on it :lol: :lol: as I seems to forget names when I am deleting :mrgreen: 8)

Ahh thats a good point when people use different names fair shout :lol: :P

I just had to check :lol: And yes you are still there ..... PHEW 8)
missyolga
12 years ago
NeoSEC28 wrote:
missyolga wrote:
NeoSEC28 wrote:
missyolga wrote:
Jarci, are you on my neighbourslist?

Sorry Missy couldnt help say this but.......... Surely you know whos on your friends list? :lol:

I think hahaha, its way tooo big, but when people have different names for the game, who can follow then :x :evil: ,

And are you sure your still on it :lol: :lol: as I seems to forget names when I am deleting :mrgreen: 8)

Ahh thats a good point when people use different names fair shout :lol: :P

I just had to check :lol: And yes you are still there ..... PHEW 8)

Phew???? Damn, I got rid of the wrong one then :shock:

( just teasing you LOL )
NeoSEC28
12 years ago
missyolga wrote:

Phew???? Damn, I got rid of the wrong one then :shock:

( just teasing you LOL )

:shock: :shock: :shock: :shock: :shock: :shock: :mrgreen:

Wouldnt blame ya to delete my town it not the greatest :P
davesmurano
New Spectator
12 years ago
my curiosity is killing me. i'm going to send you an invite jarci. i'll feel bad removing a person but there's one that hasn't played in a long time. lol
icegryllz
12 years ago
sent an invite, how long will it take roughly?
lissarv68
12 years ago
jarci1 wrote:

B+ is great, but the people within the A range are doing two things that you aren't.
1. You do not have much of a macro concept. Houses are with houses and the jail is on the edge of town, but if you look at people with As it is like they sat down with a pen and paper and planned where every building was going such that it complimented each other. They have rivers or lakes that flow through their town that make sense. They have forests where there should be forests.
2. You are not showing me anything that I haven't seen anywhere else. I know...I know...this is tough, but we all need to get those creative juices flowing.
If I wanted to get picky I would also say the brown and white houses at the top seem misguided and there still is a little bit of cramping but not as bad as others.
.

I hate to resurrect this post but something has been bothering me about it.

First off - who is this "we". First you say that "I" will be doing this and "I" will be doing that and then it switches to "we" and "panel of judges". So which is it, exactly?

Second - somebody asked if this "team of judges" are included in the grades. The question was ignored. So who is this team? Where are their towns?

Third - do you know what a macro concept is? Explain it. I'm sure those eager to be judged would like to know what you think a macro concept is.

Just asking the questions for clarification because if you are going to put this sort of post out there, grading people who did not ask to be graded, then you should answer the questions and be prepared to be scrunitized.