Speculation Ahoy big stuff to come

"someonewashere;1512274" wrote:
Even if Shelbyville happens (and since LP said so, it will happen, even if EA says no it will still happen) people are still disappointed, at the end of the event they'll say something about mixed feelings or a weak start with a strong finish, how the latter half "saved" the first act,
why? cause they are disappointed with what they first saw, people still judge books by their cover and still eat with their eyes.

*snip*

I waited to see a complete list of what we'll be getting to completely make up my mind - and I'm still not impressed.

From the religious stand point, I'm neutral. I'd prefer something as generic as possible (like the last Christmas). Concentrating more on presents and the holidays being what they are - a mix of many beliefs. I lose interest when it becomes too specific to one particular sect. Not loving the theme any more than I would have liked it if it concentrated more on the Christian religious aspects (more Jesus, less Santa).

Mostly I don't like the theme because it's way too Clash of the Clones-ish. It's not even bright and colorful Ren Fair-ish, it's just rocks and dull colors - and while I totally get where and how the European tappers appreciate it more; it's just a little too eurocentric for my taste.

But those are even secondary complaints I could have rolled with (not every event is going to make everyone happy). I'm sorry, it's just not major event material. The new material/items being offered are much lower in count (and, impo, in quality) than what we usually get for a major event.

Had this been a little ten day mini-event, I would totally be defending it from the complainers. But as is, it is kind of a meager offering for one of the most anticipated events of the year and a bit of a disappointment.