Here is my entry:
http://i.imgur.com/8GkmwuU.jpg?1
Worship:
Apu-pray to Ganesh
8 thumbs-up in the church-Bart, Homer, Lisa, Marge, Milhouse, Lovejoy, Flanders & Wiggum
Sins/vices:
Duffman: Partying outside church
Fat Tony: getting rid of problem
Krusty: inflating self-importance
Krabapple: smoking
Hibbert: sacrificing principles
Snake: robbing the Kwik e mart
Moe: smuggling endangered species
Mr Burns: disposing of nuclear waste
Cletus: dumpster diving
Barney: passed out
CBG: reading comic(?)
Quimby: embezzling money
I also had Smithers as a drunken wreck, but he wandered away. Oh, well.
Bonus to theme: alternately, Fat Tony could be doing community service by cleaning up Reindeer dung.
I'll let the facilitator and any judges determine the final scoring.