There is no bug. You changed the rarity of the card by applying other evos, so now he doesn't fit into the "El Pibe de Oro" evolution. Obviously, there is nothing you can do now.
No, it is not clear at all. EA should not just list these requirements: 89 OVR, Special Item, max 10 PlayStyles, max 2 PlayStyles +. Instead, they should explicitly state: "Only players who have completed Dream Maradona 1, 2, or 3 are eligible."
As you can see in the screenshot, my card still meets all the "El Pibe de Oro" requirements even after applying other evolutions. EA is wrong here, and they should fix this bug or allow players to revert their evolutions.
Many of us have wasted a lot of time and effort because of this misleading system. EA needs to address this issue ASAP.
