Forum Discussion

AiredMania's avatar
AiredMania
New Adventurer
1 year ago

Too Many 4 Stars

Too many 4 star players in recruiting. If you’re not top 100 (in my opinion), you’re not a 4 star recruit. You can’t be ranked 355th in the country and be a 4 star guy lol

4 Replies

  • @AiredMania I could be wrong here but they told us they built it off of real class rating numbers..... here is a quick data point I just found from 247composite.

    On the 247 Composite there are roughly 30-35 5 stars, 300-330 4 stars, 2000 3 stars, and 400-500 2 stars. There aren't any "1 star" recruits.
  • AiredMania's avatar
    AiredMania
    New Adventurer
    1 year ago

    I don’t just mean “too many players are undeserving of the distinction”, i mean the game generates too many 70 to 76-ish rated players. It leads to too much parity among the schools.

    I know it sounds crazy but the elite schools aren’t elite enough and the bad ones aren’t bad enough.

  • Dirty_Smeegs_33's avatar
    Dirty_Smeegs_33
    Seasoned Veteran
    1 year ago

    @AiredManiaI hear you on that one! Wait until you see how wonky the player progression is too. No matter what you do to player progression sliders everyone ends up in low 80's.

  • Not every high school football player is rated, many good players end up on teams as walk ons or are picked up by colleges who know how to scout.

Featured Places

Node avatar for College Football 25 Dynasty

College Football 25 Dynasty

Discuss your Dynasty with the EA SPORTS™ College Football 25 community.Latest Activity: 11 months ago
1,406 Posts