Forum Discussion

Akipekopeko's avatar
Akipekopeko
Rising Hotshot
9 hours ago

Legends:Designer’s Notes

I have reviewed the recently published Designer’s Notes ( https://www.ea.com/en-us/games/apex-legends/apex-legends/news/29-0-designers-notes ).

Regarding the scatter plot showing the relationship between win rate and pick rate for each character (with the average set at 0,0), I have several concerns.

  • Why are the axes not symmetrical? The current scaling makes it difficult to visually identify the distribution of outliers, such as Octane or Horizon. Furthermore, this visualization clusters most legends near the center, making it hard to discern the lack of characters with significantly low pick rates.

  • Is this truly the right priority?In the notes, you focus heavily on Vantage, Conduit, and Alter. However, all of these characters fall within a ±5% range of the average.  (Personally, I found the data for Alter surprising, as I perceived her to be significantly stronger).

  • Does this not suggest that the issue is more structural rather than just individual character balance? The legends with abnormally high pick and win rates are almost exclusively limited to the Skirmisher and Assault classes.

To be honest, it is difficult to welcome new legends while the current roster remains so unbalanced. I strongly believe that the priority should be achieving proper balance with the existing legends first, rather than further increasing the number of characters requiring adjustment.

1 Reply

  • The axes are asymmetrical to accommodate the data points without creating a lot of empty space on the chart. I get that it requires the reader to really pay attention to understand what they're looking at, but it makes sense.

    Personally I was surprised by the data on Octane and Horizon. He's being addressed by the addition of the new legend who, in theory, will dilute his pick rate. But what about Horizon? Always over-powered and never addressed.

    I can agree completely that the game didn't need a new legend. This one in particular seems to have been created for the sole purpose of splitting the Octane audience. More game clutter, imo. Or as someone else put it, "slop."

    From my point of view a legend tune for Overclocked should have addressed the entire right side of the graph and not just Octane. Is Maggie not a problem? Wraith? Horizon? It all makes me wonder if the invisible Y axis would be labeled "dollars spent in the store," and that's where those four legends also excel.

    When did I get so cynical?

Featured Places

Node avatar for Apex Legends Feedback

Apex Legends Feedback

Give feedback about the Legends, maps, weapons, loot and more in the Apex Legends community forums.Latest Activity: 4 minutes ago
34,623 Posts