Forum Discussion
Trokey66
4 years agoSeasoned Ace
@-DFA-Thump Although loosely based on a true story, the exploits in Saving Private Ryan where wholly fictional and therefore inaccurate however, the story was told in an authentic way.
Video games, especially sand box FPS such as Battlefield are just entertainment but at best, they could inspire the user to research actions depicted from more reliable sources.
How accurate is it that all battles depicted only ever had 64 combatants at any one time?
How accurate is it that a side that historically lost a given battle can win.
Let's ignore the fact that a German can use a gold Thompson or a Brit a Gold STG.
Simply put, an authentic thing can be used in an inaccurate way/setting but never the less, remain authentic to the over all experience.
Video games, especially sand box FPS such as Battlefield are just entertainment but at best, they could inspire the user to research actions depicted from more reliable sources.
How accurate is it that all battles depicted only ever had 64 combatants at any one time?
How accurate is it that a side that historically lost a given battle can win.
Let's ignore the fact that a German can use a gold Thompson or a Brit a Gold STG.
Simply put, an authentic thing can be used in an inaccurate way/setting but never the less, remain authentic to the over all experience.
4 years ago
@Trokey66 There's a very big difference between mirroring and indisputably rewriting history for the sake of pandering which was exactly what DICE/EA were doing.
As far as accuracy of tracking each 64 people on a battlefield that occurred before the concept of a computer existed as it exactly happened in history is simply impossible. You couldn't ask for that level of accuracy for people walking into the very theater to watch Saving Private Ryan during opening release. It doesn't mean that you can go off the rails and "be just close enough" (i.e. people did a thing somewhere at some point) and sell it the way DICE/EA did. Soderlund literally said his daughter was the reason why that character existed...
The fact that a German can hold a gold Thompson and Brita a Gold STG only serves to prove my point. So what's exactly is yours?
I'll agree that an authentic thing can be used in somewhat inaccurate ways/settings but not to the sheer extent that DICE/EA did and how they sold it.
As far as accuracy of tracking each 64 people on a battlefield that occurred before the concept of a computer existed as it exactly happened in history is simply impossible. You couldn't ask for that level of accuracy for people walking into the very theater to watch Saving Private Ryan during opening release. It doesn't mean that you can go off the rails and "be just close enough" (i.e. people did a thing somewhere at some point) and sell it the way DICE/EA did. Soderlund literally said his daughter was the reason why that character existed...
The fact that a German can hold a gold Thompson and Brita a Gold STG only serves to prove my point. So what's exactly is yours?
I'll agree that an authentic thing can be used in somewhat inaccurate ways/settings but not to the sheer extent that DICE/EA did and how they sold it.
About Battlefield 2042 General Discussion
Discuss the latest news and game information around Battlefield 2042 in the community forums.16,092 PostsLatest Activity: 23 minutes ago
Recent Discussions
- 23 minutes ago
- 42 minutes ago
- 45 minutes ago
- 2 hours ago
- 3 hours ago