All-Americans
The All-American selections are busted. I had a CB lead the nation in interceptions, cause 3 fumbles and score 4 tds and didn’t even make second team. In fact, my team filled the defensive player awa...
Forum Discussion
If you actually take a closer look, I think it’s based off of overall ratings which is a very lazy and poor take from EA
@ncballer5 Yeah it should honestly be a balance between overall and stats, maybe a modifier where stronger OVR ranks you higher bc you get more attention. You don't get to be an all American at WR just because your scheme supports 65 short passes a game and so you get 130 catches for 1100 yards and 10 TDs. Meanwhile a stud WR who gets double teamed all the time produces 65 catches for 990 yards and 12 TDs. Similarly a DT in the SEC getting double teamed still causing havoc may have lower stats than a DT at WMU but that doesn't mean the WMU DT is more deserving of the award. Stats certainly should play a factor but OVR and honestly Conference Prestige to some extent should also weigh into this.
