Forum Discussion
Hey, Folks
We wanted to jump in and let everyone know that the feedback on this thread has been passed along to the team for review.
Not hearing anything on feedback can be frustrating as you never really know if it was reviewed, sent up, or if changes will be made to the game itself.
Some updates like these changes are being made, we won't know or have the info until patch notes are released so we ask that everyone keep an eye on those notes.
We also want you to continue providing feedback as we continue to send that over to the right teams for review so that they can continue to make improvements that players want out of their games.
We do apologize that some threads have gone untouched and we are reviewing those and will get them as soon as we can. We do see the feedback daily, and we are doing what we can to provide recognition for the feedback you have provided.
Cheers!
- 12 months ago
@EA_ShepardThank you for the response. I think that is mostly what this thread is asking for - an open line of communication that acknowledges that EA is paying attention.
- 12 months ago@tjstorm23 don't fall for it. They come on here once every two weeks and say the same thing. They aren't listening. They don't care. We got played.
I lived 11 years without a college football game. I had a trash one for a couple of weeks but my life was just fine without it. I won't be buying another.- brad921111 months agoSeasoned Hotshot
Still silence I see… moved to checking in once or twice a week to see if I can reinstall since I couldn’t get refund. I know it won’t happen but I’m still naive against my better judgement lol.
- 12 months ago
@EA_Shepard wrote:Hey, Folks
We wanted to jump in and let everyone know that the feedback on this thread has been passed along to the team for review.
Not hearing anything on feedback can be frustrating as you never really know if it was reviewed, sent up, or if changes will be made to the game itself.
Some updates like these changes are being made, we won't know or have the info until patch notes are released so we ask that everyone keep an eye on those notes.
We also want you to continue providing feedback as we continue to send that over to the right teams for review so that they can continue to make improvements that players want out of their games.
We do apologize that some threads have gone untouched and we are reviewing those and will get them as soon as we can. We do see the feedback daily, and we are doing what we can to provide recognition for the feedback you have provided.
Cheers!Surely, by “changes being made,” you mean the ability to change numbers and facial features and skin tone to Non-NIL players and adding the ability to edit ratings. Because that IS what we are asking for. We don’t want to be shorted, or given some patch, or a workaround, or loophole to disallow us the editing we should rightfully have. Thank you for your response, but we just don’t want another “half-fix” or “compromise.” And this is undoubtedly the largest issue among dynasty fans.
- xPats4Lifex12 months agoSeasoned Ace@ezmoneyrowdy i dont seem them fixing any of this personally... i have learned to not get my hopes up with EA. Madden 25 is even more of a dumpster fire with creation. I have asked for YEARS for new generic faces or a face editor for draft classes and AGAIN... the SAME PS2 garbage generic faces... What makes me even more mad is how different the equipment is between both games. I get the NFL is more strict with equipment but to not see knee braces in M25, or all the new name brand arm sleeves, shoulder brace, or 3/4 sleeves in CFB is frustrating. They simply do not care about people who like creation/customization and only focus on online modes that will give them more $
- xPats4Lifex12 months agoSeasoned Ace
Lets talk about this as well... Since this thread seems to CARE about customization here is my thought with this...(these screenshots are from the first skin tone on both team builders)
CFB: Doesn't have create a player, doesnt have option to edit recruits but gives THOUSANDS on NEXT GEN looking faces that WE CANT EVEN USE unless we are using team builder... Ruins CFB for me
M25: Pushes the same PS2 generic garbage looking faces for the like 10th year in a row. Absolutely unacceptable that CFB made all these new faces but NONE of them can be put in M25 for what reason??? Same looking draft class players with VERY FEW outdated face options. Ruins M25 for me.
Conclusion:
EA does NOT care about customization for any offline players and will give you the bare minimum each year... EA FC, NHL, NBA2K, MLB The Show are all YEAR and miles ahead of EA as far as character customization and its ridiculous. The neglect to offline players is UNACCEPTABLE
- 12 months ago
@Canadeion wrote:"We are listening, thanks for the feedback, we will try to make changes..."
How about some specifics here?
"We understand that you want to edit generic players to assist with immersion, we can likely add the ability to edit numbers and ratings, but we might not be able to allow names and faces for legal reasons..."
Or SOMETHING other than generic drivel that means nothing to anyone.
They sent the Community Manager out to be a meat shield for complaints. I'd honestly be surprised if he has any direct communication with developers. I'm sure they're keeping them in the dark as much as us. EA needs to comment, but when they do it's not going to come from the CM, it'll be some cryptic emoji tweet from one of the devs.
- 12 months ago@ezmoneyrowdy The replies are intentionally vague as to not overpromise and under deliver. I didn't see anything there that would make me believe that player editing will be addressed in any way shape form or fashion. The thing is I'm not expecting it, there will be more improvements to the game for sure, but it won't be the changes that many people are clamoring for, that's just not how this ever goes.
Player editing, new recruit generation and their numbers, top 25 rankings and sim stats are all still enormous issues in this game. There is likely no way all of these issues get fixed with somehow breaking the game in another way. I really don't expect to see sim stats fixed simply because M25-2 also released with horrible sim stats (as it always does every year) yet again!!
It's unfathomable the sheer lack of control I have over the many aspects of dynasty/franchise. We keep losing so many things in these modes that we don't remember things that have been changed that don't make the game better. Why is it that I have my options set to kickoff for the game and there are multiple games that I recieve the ball to start the game. I can't see the coin toss, but I know it's coded in the game because I see it in OT games. Why was this ever removed and why have we just settled for it's absence? Simply because there are so many other broken area of the game that you forget about it and move on. My point is why does the setting as terribly unrealistic as it is, exist in the game if it doesn't work properly?
- 12 months ago
Don’t give me hope
- 12 months ago
Time will only tell what they have in store with the updates. I will not be picking this game back up until customization within dynasty is an available option again. It ruins the entire immersive experience that dynasty is supposed to offer.
- 12 months ago
Thanks for the update, albeit your response is intentionally a bit vague, and doesn't give me much confidence the team//devs/EA are willing to address this issue publicly in full.
About College Football 25 Dynasty
Recent Discussions
- 3 days ago
- 4 days ago
- 6 days ago
- 7 days ago