Forum Discussion

kevncobb's avatar
6 months ago

I'll say what everyone is thinking, but it's too controversial to say.

There are too many white skill player recruits. And I say that being a white dude IRL. It's immersion-breaking and just plain stupid. Since when does any program recruit 3 Elusive white RBs with 90s in elusiveness?

I just finished a great season, but after reviewing my incoming class I quit the game and don't plan on playing until they allow us to edit these players.

I want to feel like I'm playing in a real universe. This screams fake.

9 Replies

  • How about all  the 5* defensive backs? 1 of the years on my dynasty the 6 top rated WR's where white & the top 5 CB's where too. LOL! But they want it to be real! I got a few of em & dripped them out!🤣🤣🤣

  • Yeahhh and it’s sad bc a lot of these YouTubers touted how realistic the recruiting classes were as far as certain skilled positions coming from specific regions. While that would be cool, it’s hard to get that immersed into the game when the players’ races are so far off. Plus talking about this is walking a PC tight rope. 

  • Exactly! They bragged about how recruiting pipelines reflect real-life demographics but didn't include this. There should be more black skill players than white. Christian McCaffrey is an anomaly -- not the norm. Sorry if reality offends anyone.

    I realize that DEI politics probably won't allow them to hardcode a skin color skill bias. But surely they can let us edit our offline dynasty.

  • With all of the other problems in this game, this way down on my list of concerns.  

  • Darksim15's avatar
    Darksim15
    Rising Traveler
    6 months ago

    @Sgoforth5 wrote:

    With all of the other problems in this game, this way down on my list of concerns.  


    Exactly what I was going to say. Let's worry about being able to get the recruits into proper positions and being able to see the scoreboard first.

  • offline dynasty isn't even playable, cosmetics unfortunately has taken a back seat, which is sad and pathetic. 

    College Football Revamped is clearly the better overall game at the current moment, which again, is pathetic to have to admit in 2024.

  • lolllll the nicer way to say this is "the demographic algorithms used to create recruits needs tuning".

    This is most evident with the insane names we see players getting: brown skin players with blonde hair named Tyler Chan. White runningbacks named DeAndre.

    But yeah, we all see it, its kinda funny but wish it would be better.

  • This game mode is pretty much unplayable. People play dynasty for immersion. They are far too many white skill position players. It's ridiculous and is making me want to stop playing the game. It's not even 50/50. Most of the players generated are white regardless of what position they play. EA is just god awful at making games. I am so angry I bought this game. I need a refund. 

About College Football 25 Dynasty

Discuss your Dynasty with the EA SPORTS™ College Football 25 community.1,340 PostsLatest Activity: 2 hours ago