Highschool challenges

So this a weird thing ive run into now, i have 3 corners tow bump and runs and one field. the first guy i made was bump and run and played on the bulldogs i had a great career no heisman even thought i broke the recorded for season and career  interceptions. that guy i saved him to madden ready, so i made another guy bump and run also to see if i can win the heisman  he ends up on norte dame doing pretty good so far , both these guys end the high school 5 star corners.

Now i think i should really try a different style corner instead of 2 bump and run , so i make the field corner, now no matter the setting all american or heisman , durning the challenges no matter if i try to bait the qb or stop a run the plays always now suddenly dont even come my way period. the runs i can stop by just disregarding my side and going to the other side but pass breakups or intercepts the qb wont even look my way even playing way off the WR. So i barely get out of highschool a 4 star with this guy ive erased him and tried a few time with all the same results . whatever side i move to the qb avoids like the plauge