EA has put very little effort into Road to CFP this year and it shows. The items you describe above happen to all of us sadly.
This game mode was a blast in 25 now all EA wants is for you to play CUT and shell out more $$$.
- Playing against Smith from OSU or Williams from Bama, your defenders actually get nerfed in a attempt to make those player look better then what they are.
- Lack to team diversity(due to abilities being nerfed into the ground) allow for even more players to use Bama or OSU so your gonna sadly see them make every catch possible, while your star WR hands turn into brick wall....even on position catches.
The only advice I can give you is post you vid and tag EA. Trust me, we all fill you pain.