Correct me if I'm misunderstanding you. I suspect the people who say "Lucanis is written better for Neve than for Rook" aren't picking up on how well the different characters mesh. Instead, I think it's just that if you have Lucanis and Neve in the party together very often, they get more opportunities to banter and talk than Lucanis does with Rook, and a lot of folks pick up a flirty vibe from a lot of what they say to each other. Because you're right, Rook can end up with a range of personality types, and I think for what we did get, Lucanis can mesh pretty well with all of them.
I think this is just a symptom of them taking away the conversation wheel and being able to talk at-will to your companions. Rook gets less convo time compared to the excellent banter.
It's not a difficult fix, though. If folks don't like how Lucanis and Neve interact, then just don't keep them in a party together very often.
100%! Rook is always talking to everyone else, while others get to choose WHO they spend time with. So, if Lucanis mostly spends time with Neve for example, it stands to reason that they may flirt, be interested with each other, get married, have kids, and ultimately annoy the **bleep** out of Rook. Rook be like: 😭
