Forum Discussion

GuardianD671's avatar
5 years ago

Will EA Desktop have settings as in post

i dont want an app that i am forced to switch to because origin is being killed off, unless:

1) it has setting to prevent it always running in background at windows start. i want to run origin when i want to run an origin game and i dont even like webhelper using resources. this thing must only run when i want to play what used to be an origin game and is now in this new thing.

2) additionally, when i close it, i want it to CLOSE not just secretly minimise to the sys tray and pretend to be closed. because generally im on another platform running a non EA game and dont want this thing wasting resources and downloading an update when im in the middle of gaming, just because it doesnt know im gaming because im not using a game run from it. i am disturbed by the recent trend for steam and other clients to not close the application when you click the close window thing top right. yes i know its called 'close window' not 'exit' but why would i want to close just the window and in reality just minimise it? i wouldnt would i? its no good without a window to run a game from, for me, so i want the options to have a 'exit app on click close window x ' setting. because otherwise i will just have to use the menu and exit selection, which it must definitely have. 

the only reason i have two of these clients running when i run a game is like with Fallen Order, where i bought on steam so i could review it, even though nobody reads my reviews, and have the discussions which origin does not have forums. i also run assassins creed games from steam which need uplay open. otherwise i only want one storefront 'app' open at once.

3) it doesnt try to force me to use the windows store app. i dont like 'app' rubbish anyway. if i have to have this, i want a download from a proper site like with origin, not any of this phone app rubbish. i dont want to open windows store app at all since it wants to download a million updates for apps i cant uninstall but never use.

4) i still want a wishlist

5) still want to be able to organise the games into faves etc. and pick size of the game icon on the screen. i hated the epic launcher because visually its a nightmare, a mass of clashing colours and huge pictures seemingly placed by a mad clown. now i understand this is because of apple and its iphones and since smart phone users can no longer read because they have been trained to work by pictures and swiping with pudgy fingers on the screen - but i own a pc, not a phone. i game on this gaming laptop, and i want a nice looking view of my games, not a massive scrolling list of clashing colours, like epic was, and steam was nearly as bad, though thankfully they have removed the soul-less grey behind their mandatory icons update. i trust you wont make that mistake, since i dont see any preview screenshots of the UI. for a while i could barely use steam after that update (not just the clashing colours on grey, it was also how it had severe memory leak adding 500kb of ram used each game page you looked at, thanks to chromium). 

those are the important ones spring to mind. after the steam update, origin actually looked good by comparison despite its lack of steam's groups and discussions. i just pray you havent gone down the 'idiots only like pictures' route epic seemed to.

6 Replies

  • @GuardianD671 

    Heya,

    Thanks for taking the time to provide your feedback about the EA Desktop Beta!

    I'll dive straight in to answer your comments.

    1. Startup settings can always be adjusted via Windows -> Task Manager settings. This doesn't have to be done in-client.
    2. If you click "X", you will minimize. If you select Menu -> Exit, the client will close completely.
    3. A wishlist isn't yet available during the Beta, but feedback on this feature has been noted!
    4. I'll make sure the team gets this feedback as well.

    I hope your experience has been pleasant so far. If you have any additional thoughts, we'd love to hear more :-)

    Cheers,

  • Menteless's avatar
    Menteless
    4 years ago

    "If you click "X", you will minimize. If you select Menu -> Exit, the client will close completely."

    Okay well this is a bug that needs to be fixed. Clicking X does not mean minimize or hide to system tray. X means close. Goodbye. Gone. Go away. Stop running.

    Please fix this issue, I imagine its one of the simpler things you can fix with your cruddy system since its supposed to be how a window behaves by default.

  • holger1405's avatar
    holger1405
    Hero+
    4 years ago

    @Menteless 

    It is normal the behaviour of any gaming client I know, Steam, Origin, GOG, Epic and so on.

    Also normal behaviour for some other applications that are supposed to be running in the background because they provide certain functionality like the driver control centre. 

    So, no, they will not fix that, it is intended behaviour.

  • Menteless's avatar
    Menteless
    4 years ago

    I'd be willing to accept that if they behaved like many of the other programs and offered you the ability to turn that functionality off. Other programs doing it without the option to turn it off doesn't make it right. For any of them.

    Steam is the only one I want running in the background all the time because 99% of my games are there, as are 100% of my friends. I like the mission GOG is on for DRM-less games, but I don't use it enough, I should be able to set it to actually close. Epic... Epic is barely a gaming client. Regardless, Epic actually DOES allow you to turn that feature off. Amazing how even a [Removed by CM] such as Epic can do that for us.

    It's stupid and lazy programming not to allow us to turn it off. If I want or need something running in the background I will let it run in the background, otherwise when I want something to close, I expect it to close as the "close" button is supposed to do. If by "driver control center" you mean something such as Nvidia Geforce Experience, you do not need that running at all ever. If you would like the features of it such as Shadowplay to be available, sure. Otherwise you can quit out of it entirely and be fine. But Nvidia should also put the option to not have it minimize to the system tray.

    As for Origin, and soon to-be EA Desktop... they should definitely have it considering barely anyone uses them anyways. Why would someone want them running in the background longer than needed? In my experience with EA Desktop it even seems it wants to quit completely more than I want it too considering how often it loves crashing and needing to be restarted.

    So once again, I hope EA can find it in their sad, dead, empty hearts to fix this issue and not be the absolute *-stain of a company they're seemingly on the march to continue being. I won't be surprised if they decide to keep it as-is, but then I might just have to find other avenues of playing EA games without Origin or Desktop. I hear Sims 4 runs perfectly fine without any EA programs running.

  • holger1405's avatar
    holger1405
    Hero+
    4 years ago

    @Menteless 


    Menteless wrote:

    I expect it to close as the "close" button is supposed to do. If by "driver control center" you mean something such as Nvidia Geforce Experience,


    No, I mean the NVIDIA control Center.

    And I could list about two dozen other applications that do it too.


    Menteless wrote:

    As for Origin, and soon to-be EA Desktop... they should definitely have it considering barely anyone uses them anyways.


    And you know that how? 🤔

    It is two clicks instead of one....  🙄

  • EA_Darko's avatar
    EA_Darko
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    4 years ago

    Hey all, I'm going to go ahead and lock this thread as it's going around in circles.

    When posting on AHQ @Menteless please do so in a polite and constructive manner.

    Darko

About EA app General Discussion

Got EA app questions? Let's chat here!1,585 PostsLatest Activity: 4 hours ago