@LABoog4 wrote:
What would the fans do IRL if Ajax brought in a manager who was defensive and played 5-3-2 or something similar? Would it be an instant rejection or wait to see what results happen?
Demand a new manager..., instantly.
- Last season, John van 't Schip became crisis-manager. Ajax until then scored 8 points from 9 games. Under Van 't Schip in 4-3-3 suddenly they achieved 27 points out of 11 games. But a cup humiliation (knocked out by amateur side), struggles in European football and a single defeat in February 2024, meant that Van 't Schip changed to a 5-4-1 and that was it..., people were soon done with him: only 21 points from the last 13 games.
- Martin Jol (2009-2010) changed to a 4-4-2 to fit in Luis Suarez with Mounir El Hamdaoui up front.Within a matter of games, he was out.
- Ronald Koeman (2001-2005) is the only one who briefly played 4-4-2 and achieved succes with a double in 2002: he paired Zlatan with Nikos Machlas and he became coach because before him, Co Adriaanse came up with the weirdest tactics: then 3-5-2, then 4-2-4, then 4-3-3 and the next week again something completely different.
So, that's why you see so many managers with Ajax-DNA: Rinus Michels, Johan Cruijff, Louis van Gaal, Ronald Koeman, Danny Blind, Marco van Basten, Frank de Boer, Hedwiges Maduro, John van 't Schip - all ex-players of the club and later managers. They know the club inside out and they know fans don't tolerate anything different than 4-3-3 for long; not even a Champions League win would change their minds.