Hey, I’m in almost the exact same situation and wanted to share my experience.
I’m a free-to-play FC 26 player, two years in, never bought or sold coins. I got restricted after a few sales during the La Liga TOTS period when the market was highly volatile. Some players spiked due to evo speculation and buyers simply willing to pay above market value on public listings. I had zero control over that.
Just like you I’ve submitted multiple appeals and keep getting the same automated rejection with no specific transaction mentioned and no real explanation. It’s clearly not being reviewed by a human.
The frustrating part is that tradable pack rewards, duplicates, SBC fodder, all of it is stuck. As a free-to-play player the whole point of trading small margins is to fund evos and SBCs. Without the transfer market that’s basically gone.
I completely agree with you that the system needs proper human review for cases like ours. An automated system flagging isolated high-price sales without looking at the full account history is not a fair process.
Hope we both get this sorted. If you find a way through, please share it here.