[FEEDBACK] - Icon Sir Bobby Charlton

I like the idea, and the challenge was decent—well-balanced with the AI, so skilled players could beat it on the first try. But those are really the only two good things about Icon-Making challenges.

If we’re celebrating certain players, their OVR needs to be higher to give them the respect they deserve, plain and simple. Otherwise, their cards just end up being used for exchanges or sit in the inventory. The ranking doesn’t need to be at 4; it can be lower, so players can use Mascheranos if they want to go higher. However, the base OVR is way too low. I’m not saying they should be bumped up to 107 base or 112 (rank 5/gold), but a 100 OVR Charlton card being raised to 104 feels off and disrespectful to the player, especially considering he has his own standalone challenge. Cards like those from the Heroes event would be a much better fit or even match it up with King/Solskjaer challenges (although that does still feel like OVR too low). Otherwise, Charlton won’t make it into anyone’s lineup unless they’re running a themed team with MUFC or England icons.

His in-game performance is poor too, and after trying a few friendlies, I can already tell he’ll just end up as fodder. It’s the same situation as with Maradona. Sure, it’s nice he’s back in the game, but Charlton's card feels like a waste of time, just like Maradona’s celebration card. Even a lower OVR 97 unranked Gullit, played out of position, performs better than those two. And adding any 100 or below CAM Icon (like 100 Del Piero) is a major upgrade too.

So, yeah, if you want to make a real impact and truly celebrate players with these events, their stats need to go up.