'My History' under Compare stats only ever shows last game/last oponent

In the last few years of Madden iterations I used to be able to go to "My History' under "Compare Stats to see the last 15-20 online opponents I had played and look at my win / loss history (and the names of the players I had played.  On Madden 24 I only ever  see the last opponent I have played.  I asked some of my friends who play online and they can see the listing of the last 15-20  players they have played still.   

Help?   How can this be fixed?  is anyone else having this problem?

I have the PS5 with no cd drive so I have to download all of my games.