Madden Causing PS5 to Shutdown due to Overheating

I know this isn't a hardware issue as my PS5 is regularly cleaned, both internally and externally, and no other game causes this issue. I can play other, more graphically intensive games for hours but Madden without fail causes a shutdown.

It's happening when I go into a cutscene in superstar mode. I hear the fans whir up loudly and a few seconds later my PS5 shuts down. I can't play the game because I don't want to keep risking my PS5 with these shut downs. I've had 3 since I got the game yesterday.