Forum Discussion

jpcerutti1's avatar
8 years ago

Spoiler: Krogan Scouts or Raeka? Why?

And as followup, how did you resolve the choice with Sarissa? I wonder if people feel differently based on the order they made these choices or made them completely separate things. I also just like to hear why people do the things they do. 🙂 

It is arguably the toughest decision you have to make in the game. I played it both ways to see the results and to decide if I was comfortable with them.

Spoiler

Raeka.

Pathfinders should have each other's backs and she had mine once already halfway through the mission. That she speaks up for you with the Nexus for Meridian was the scene that made having to leave the scouts and disappointing Drack, and apparently the entire Krogan race, tolerable.

I like both Drack and Kesh as characters and that they don't flex a little on "Krogan first", even as progressives, is disappointing. Rakea being the "bigger man" in the immediate followup and Drack giving her a hard time for being alive after watching nearly an entire ark get exhalted (over four scouts getting exhalted) was a real turnoff. Kesh throwing in her two cents, and that you have more than one followup with them over you not doing what they wanted... That Kesh does as well AND you miss the only optional non-romance cutscene in the game? Thanks Bioware, I just love the Krogan now.

If it goes the other way one brief mention by Tann, and acceptance, and we move on. Like Tann is the ugly prejudiced one here. 😞 That Drack is both condescending and gloats if you choose the scouts doesn't help make deciding for them any easier either - I guess that's just there to pull the sting out of letting a pathfinder die (especially if you try to hold Sarissa accountable).

Sarissa, BUT we face the music.

If it wan't for Cora I think I would of let it be. What I wanted her to get from it was more important, for me, than anything else. It is, after all, her loyalty mission. From the mission I get that Vederia is just way too green and unready to be a pathfinder which complicates it. People make mistakes and choices that don't fit what was expected of them - but if you're going to do either, right or wrong, you need to own it. After that if you want to apologize or explain, that's up to you. If they want to accept it or forgive, that's up to them.

I would rather she just follow my lead whenever *I*  end up making a choice she doesn't agree with, and doesn't leave me to die, but we need to forgive Sarissa too. If she, somewhere down the road, does what she thinks will save the galaxy over just saving me she'll be forgiven - even if I have to do it posthumously. 🙂


77 Replies

  • EgoMania's avatar
    EgoMania
    Seasoned Ace
    8 years ago

    @arthurh3535 wrote:

    Your binary choice ignores the innocent civilian Salarians.


    Innocent Salarians....good one 😇

    Still, considering the limited number of Krogan that were allowed to come along and me saving the Salarian ark with thousands of them on board, I think the scouts are the fairest choice just the same.

    And the moral choice between letting people die or be kettified is still an interesting choice regardless of who is innocent or not, because in the end they all are innocent and didn't deserve to die, so that really is not a determining factor here.

  • Random civilian salarians that did not sign up to be put in a dangerous situation vs krogan scouts that knew they were scouting a dangerous alien race.

    It makes a small difference. Basically soldier vs. civilian.
  • EgoMania's avatar
    EgoMania
    Seasoned Ace
    8 years ago

    @arthurh3535 wrote:
    Random civilian salarians that did not sign up to be put in a dangerous situation vs krogan scouts that knew they were scouting a dangerous alien race.

    It makes a small difference. Basically soldier vs. civilian.

    Everybody signed up for dangerous situations. Nobody knew what would happen on this incredible adventure. The fact that the Krogan were actively fighting the Kett seems an odd reason to make their lives worth less. Survival is still a numbers game and the Krogan have two strikes against them: Very limited numbers by comparison and an uncured Genophage in their case.


  • @EgoMania wrote:

    @arthurh3535 wrote:
    Random civilian salarians that did not sign up to be put in a dangerous situation vs krogan scouts that knew they were scouting a dangerous alien race.

    It makes a small difference. Basically soldier vs. civilian.

    Everybody signed up for dangerous situations. Nobody knew what would happen on this incredible adventure. The fact that the Krogan were actively fighting the Kett seems an odd reason to make their lives worth less. Survival is still a numbers game and the Krogan have two strikes against them: Very limited numbers by comparison and an uncured Genophage in their case.


    No, not everyone signed up to be a combat heavy. In fact, most of them don't even know how to use guns. Drack's scouts, OTOH, are picked by him on ability over looks.

  • Anonymous's avatar
    Anonymous
    8 years ago

    i usually go with raeka for reasons i posted earlier, however... raeka decided to go on a suicide mission against my characters advice to save a few more salarian prisoners, the krogan didn't have a choice in the matter. not much of a distinction, but it's something a few of my characters consider, though it doesn't have much impact on the decision making. 

  • fudgietroll's avatar
    fudgietroll
    8 years ago

    @arthurh3535 wrote:

    @EgoMania wrote:

    @arthurh3535 wrote:
    Random civilian salarians that did not sign up to be put in a dangerous situation vs krogan scouts that knew they were scouting a dangerous alien race.

    It makes a small difference. Basically soldier vs. civilian.

    Everybody signed up for dangerous situations. Nobody knew what would happen on this incredible adventure. The fact that the Krogan were actively fighting the Kett seems an odd reason to make their lives worth less. Survival is still a numbers game and the Krogan have two strikes against them: Very limited numbers by comparison and an uncured Genophage in their case.


    No, not everyone signed up to be a combat heavy. In fact, most of them don't even know how to use guns. Drack's scouts, OTOH, are picked by him on ability over looks.


    I think the idea was that everyone signed up for a leap in the dark with uncertain results and death as a distinct possibility. Also, while Raeka may be trying to free civvies she could also be trying to free STG or the guys who sold out the ark, we don't know.

  • Gilcrist's avatar
    Gilcrist
    8 years ago

    I picked Sarissa and didn't tell anyone about what she did.  I felt that she made the right decision with choosing to save her people instead of one person.  There's no need to drag her name through the mud in the process, although I have a feeling a later game in the series might bring that out and drag me down with her.

    I was really torn about the Raeka and the Salarians vs. Drack's scouts.  I actually left the game at that choice to think about it overnight.  In the end, I picked Raeka for reasons completely not mentioned above - I'm hoping that I can romance her in a later game.  Hey, you never know...

Featured Places

Node avatar for Mass Effect Franchise Discussion

Mass Effect Franchise Discussion

The fate of the galaxy lies in your hands. Join the Mass Effect community forums and tell us how you'll fight for it.Latest Activity: 7 hours ago
19,279 Posts