I am also having this problem on xbox 360. It connects to EA Nation and can search for a game, but it wont let me connect to anyone else. I have been trying with 3 other friends but we can not connect with each other, no matter how many times/different combinations of players we try. Every time we try to search for a match or create a lobby, it says 'Could not join game. Please try to join a different game.'
I have the same issue. I have two consoles X-box 360 with two different Gold accounts on each one. I already owned the game on my main Gold account. A few days ago, I purchased the game for my other Gold account. I tried to find matches using my two consoles; NAT status was open, both consoles were using fixed IP and my router set with port forwarding. I tried to find matches with a few friends as well and the same issue happened. We can connect on EA Nation (Sign in Successful!) and search for a match: "Searching for players..." >> "Joining game session..." >> "Could not join game. Please try to join a different game." It always happens. EA, the issue is real and is happening, please solve it. I purchased a second digital copy of the game on XBOX Live and now I can't play it online, so it is very unfair. Does it mean I wasted my money? You know that there are a lot of players like me around the world with this same issue.
