Forum Discussion

ImStickOnTheIce's avatar
8 months ago

Changes To Franchise Mode For NHL 25

I have spent a ton of hours playing franchise mode in NHL 24 and there are certain times in which the game becomes almost unplayable. I have compiled a list of issues and changes I would like to see for NHL 25.

1. Contract Scaling is non-existent. Once you are 10 years in, Franchise mode is almost unplayable. You have 81 Overall 7th D Defensemen asking for 7 million dollars. Meanwhile the cap has only gone up 15-20 million. With the cap going up 50%, so should players asking price. Everything should stay relative.

2. Coaching having too big of an impact. I understand how a coach is very important when it comes to real life. However, if I build a team of the greatest players of all-time, we shouldn't finish with only 50 wins and get swept in the first round. If my team has Gretzky, Orr, McDavid, and Roy, the coach shouldn't hold us back that much.

3. Completely change the way line chemistry works. Right now, X Factors have WAY too much impact on line chemistry. I can put 3 players who have 0 fit whatsoever on a line together, but if their X Factors match its a +5 boost. Meanwhile 3 players who have no X Factors but all three players have perfect line fits will only get a +2 or +3. This should not happen.

4. 6th and 7th round picks have way too much value. Under no circumstance should I be able to package these picks up and get a 3rd round pick in return.

5. Picks having inconsistent value between the draft and free agency. At the draft I have been consistently able to trade my current 2nd, 3rd, 4th etc. picks for a future 1st. Once the draft and resign-phase are complete, the 1st round pick I acquired skyrockets in value. The value of this pick should not change this much.

6. Top 5 Picks at the draft having way too much value. If I want to trade for the 1st overall pick, I have to trade an ungodly amount of assets in order to get it. However, if I trade for the player instead, I only have to trade half the amount of assets. The pick should only be as valuable as the player.

7. Let me manage multiple teams at once in franchise mode. This would be a cool feature to put in franchise mode as it is already in season mode. Image controlling a team in the western conference and eastern conference and trying to have to meet in the cup final.

8. Let me change teams through franchise mode whenever I want. If I build a super team and I want to move onto the worst team in the league, let me do so.

9. Add Trade Override. Give me full control.

10. Import Custom Draft Classes. Allow the community to create our own draft classes and allow for us to import them before every season. Not only would this make the community shared rosters 1000x better, but it would give us more control.

11. Allow us to adjust the ages of players. If I want Sidney Crosby to restart his career, I will just turn his age down to 18 and then we are good to go. This can also go alongside custom draft classes as we can make NHL legends rookies again and allow them to go through the draft. 

12. Add the ability to see a players pass/shoot bias within franchise mode. 

13. Let me edit the attributes of players within franchise mode. Of course, most users will not want to use this, but it gives us more control.

These are just a few of the things I would like to see in NHL 25. Franchise Mode as a ton of potential but recently it has been neglected and the consumer is paying the price.

6 Replies

  • @ImStickOnTheIce I absolutely love all of these… except 4 lol I figured that out in 20 and it’s how I’ve rebuilt my team every year hahaha everything else yes f’in PLEASE
  • wsoulia's avatar
    wsoulia
    Rising Traveler
    6 months ago

    @jjbyrd04,


    I bought NHL 23and I have refused to by NHL 24. I want to see tangible changes to the game going forward. I do not play online, I loved franchise mode in 19 and 20. 21 is ok at best but after that, the X-Factor addition to the game just really made it impossible to play. Also the fact that if my coach is a Forwards based coach then I don’t get players who are Balance/Cycle or Balance/Balance players and I end up have all Pinch/Cycle or Pinch/Balance players. It make no sense. We should be able to adjust those settings because who wants a Franchise player who line scheme is set up to be your 4th line player or bottom pairing Defender? 

  • jjbyrd04's avatar
    jjbyrd04
    Rising Veteran
    7 months ago

    @btmnyj811 wrote:

    Would love to have the ability to edit player ratings in franchise mode, that has been something I’ve wanted in the NHL games for a very long time. You can do this in Madden franchise mode, so why not here?



    EA has removed all editing abilities in franchise mode. Not just player ratings. It's not gonna happen my dude. The only way to bring about change is with your wallet. Stop giving them your money. 

  • btmnyj811's avatar
    btmnyj811
    Seasoned Veteran
    7 months ago

    Would love to have the ability to edit player ratings in franchise mode, that has been something I’ve wanted in the NHL games for a very long time. You can do this in Madden franchise mode, so why not here?

  • Archatius's avatar
    Archatius
    Rising Traveler
    8 months ago

    Great list! We have this control on a PC hockey sim management game and it's extremely fun to run a franchise/franchises. I would love if they would open up that control and definitely want them to address the contract issue in future years.

  • admiral745's avatar
    admiral745
    Seasoned Veteran
    8 months ago

    Oh my word yes to al!!!! Trade override! And trading for first overall picks is ridiculously hard, you have a player or prospect that would easily get you a first round pick in real life and yet you have to give that player and everything you have just to try to acquire a first round pick. Every trade is balanced heavily in favour of the team you are trading with, which is not fair at all. Make counter trades, so the trading is a negotiation. 

    Multiple team control would be amazing! 

    You should add that you should be able to host expansion drafts for more expansion drafts for more teams as your franchise goes. Not limiting it to only 1 team the entire franchise. Also allowing you to continue past 25 years by doing this. 

    You should definitely be able to change the age of players. I thought it would be cool to bring back a lot of the greats and have them start at 18 again. Or now that the next draft class is about to begin, I would love to be able to make the players  in this draft the starting draft class. 

    Also it is crazy that players ask for a tonne more money for long term contracts, when many players actually sign for less for long term contracts, as it is job security and negotiate in NMC so they have control over being moved, we should be able to negotiate the same way and have them send us counter offers on salaries/NMCs. The same with players offering deals when re-signing, since they don't want to move. Many players offer team discounts so that they won't have to change cities. 

    Great list! 100% agreed!

About NHL 24 General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and talk with us about your experiences in NHL 24.4,264 PostsLatest Activity: 3 hours ago