Forum Discussion

7df81e6108e66429's avatar
7df81e6108e66429
Seasoned Vanguard
2 years ago

My EXTENSIVE E.A NHL Wishlist...for 25 and more

Here is what I submitted directly to E.A NHL....(Edited)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hello again

First of all I would like to say Thx for tipping me off to this format and next of all I would very much APPRECIATE feedback on what you all think of my ideas. Im not implying that you owe it to me or that you have to BUT merely that I would very much appreciate it cause its always nice to gauge what you all think.

I have been playing this since 1993 off and on, admittedly,........but nonetheless I am not a Johnny Come lately either.

I have seen this game grow and have appreciated the many innovations to it through the years.

My ideas are STRICTLY Franchise(Offline) and Creation and Overall gameplay and presentation.

If I may add,I really think this title has spread itself to thin......(Too many modes within the title!)

Alot of the ideas that you have implemented through the years I had thought would be cool if you did it and low and behold you did it!

When you all first came out with Create a Player that was what REALLY did it for me!

You have expanded on that alot since those days back in 95-96 and I thank you.

I always wished that i could see my team and how they would go on after the initial season and you came out with Franchise which was another HUGE improvement!

I thought it would be great to be able to have my very own team and you guys came out with Create a Team! AWESOME!

Then Create your own Uni. came out ,........and well,..... all these things were huge for me and a whole ALOT of other players!

....and we all REALLY appreciate it,especially me!!!

My ideas could be summed up in 3 ways.....MORE,NUANCES and REALITY

So,the first thing I want to say is that in my experiences and also my opinion and that is that I know one thing players like and that is REALITY!

When playing a 10-25 year Franchise mode you obviously see so many of the same Animations and even Audio Commentary which kind of affects the REALITY factor.

So I would like to encourage WAYYYYY more animations both Micro and Macro

YEAH!........ Believe it or not that definitely enhances the game! The 24 title I noticed added a small little animation that may be miniscule but I still like it and appreciate it ,......and that is after a player comes very close to scoring a goal but is denied by the goalie they REACT by putting their head back on their stick which is on their shoulder!

What I would like to suggest Is Just WAYYYY more of it.

I would like to see the players interact with each other on the bench,interact with the crowd.....But not just simply 3-4 animations.

For example when one goes to the box there is about roughly 5-7 different animations?......I would like to see more

Making someone spit on the ice......Making the players actually talk to each other.......Emotions in their faces.........The Goalies reactions after being scored upon always seem to be them smashing their stick on the either post,which obviously they do a decent amount BUT they also sometimes simply look up into the ceiling and/or lift up their helmet and then they also very frequently drink from their water bottle. These are all simply SOME suggestions of what could be soooo many more!

It would look really authentic to show the players coming out of the tunnel and skate onto the ice with many nuances each time(Animations)

I am pleasantly surprised to see the on ice graphics(More would be nice)

I would like to see even more Logos and if I may suggest that logos should be categorized by Primary,then Secondary or Tertiary

I would also like to suggest that some of the logos should be dropped(A Hamburger?,A Pizza Slice?,A Pineapple?,A Traffic Cone?......Some are just really corny with all due respect)

I would like to see Logos like a Piranha,Tornado,Cobra,A Gator and/or Croc.....just a few ideas

More Uniform Blue prints of jerseys BUT I would like to see Blue print jersey ideas of NON NHL or AHL teams,.....Fresh ideas,Like for example all the ideas that the Seattle Kraken had to choose from but discarded in favor of their final choice.

More Pants

More Stadiums to choose from than simply the 10 originals

More Mascots

More Scoreboards

When Creating a Player I would like to choose from more than just the current cities.

For example if I want my player to come from Fon Du Lac,Wisconsin or Elkhart,Indiana(Merely examples)

More Helmets

More Shield shapes

More Colors/Hues......Thank you for adding the Mirror effect 

....You obviously have grey(Gray) for a color BUT how about Jet BLACK!

More skates

Those colorful stick wraps that you have 22-23 of(Ninja Stars,Invaders,Sticks Up)would be nice to have many more.

When Creating Players I would like to have the option to place them in the entry draft like 2 more years out.....(Right now You only have the option to place them in the current draft by their age and 4 more drafts and thats it)

More X-Factors would be nice

I would also like to see the faces that you have to choose from in Create a Player expanded from the current 217?

I would like the faces to be more discernible defined and categorized by ethnic origin(European,African,Asian,Native,etc.)

More Hairstyles than just 73

More Facial Hair styles and especially the thickness.....currently you have Clean shaven then 4 more levels BUT I would like to see another level plus different ideas like Handlebar mustache,Soul Patch,Fine edging

Even different hair textures cause obviously not all hair types and beards are the same

When it comes to Player attributes I believe you should add.....Slap shot QUICKNESS and Wrist shot QUICKNESS,How about Flexibility,How about Leadership???

Lots more Player Celebrations including

-Drop the Mic

-The Heisman

-The Incredible Hulk

-1 Arm Muscle Flex

-2 Arm Muscle Flex

-Raise the Roof

-The Lumberjack

-Forearms in an X symbol

-The Field Goal 

-Folding Arms

-The Gunfighter

-K.O Punch and Youre out

-The Diamond Symbol

-The Team(Jersey) Represent

Banner Raises for each team achievement(Presidents,Conference Champion,Stanley cup)

Ring Ceremony at teams first home game following prior years Stanley cup win

Each of my players personal achievements and firsts

-First Point

-First Goal

-First Assist

-First Hat trick

-Most points in one game

-How many Hat Tricks they have

-Most Goals in a game

-Awards won

etc.,etc.

The One idea I have, has got to do with Player development which will help further discern the differences in how they react and etc.

Its a PERSONALITY GENERATOR which will be a great innovation and enhance the Created Player experience

(The mechanics of it would be something to figure it out BUT I believe there would be like 7 personality types)

Then to further discern between the players there would also be what I call a MOOD METER which would reflect the players in game experience and attitude

I would also like to see You all TOTALLY overhaul the Fighting which has become stale,and 1 dimensional and so predictable!!

The conversation system needs VASTLY expanded dialogue!!!

There are so many more ideas that I have BUT that is just the start and some are very typical ideas and others I believe are unique and original.

This game has so much more potential and I want to have a reason to start buying it again.

As I mentioned I would VERYYYY much appreciate FEEDBACK from you all on what your thoughts are.

7 Replies

  • All good suggestion for a pure presentation. If it would all be there, for me i would consider it a big nice to have. Not more, not less.

    A more realistic game that shows off with authentic rules instead of a checking, charging and fortnite dancing would do it for me. When it comes to presentation a scan your face, like in older versions, is my only wish.

    The biggest upgrade for 25 would be a goaltender whos actually playing hockey. How to do? Just let him skate behind the net to play the puck, make Shesterkin passes thru the neutral zone, if there is the right situation, skate in front of his net when needed and dont be glued in the blue paint like for the last 30 years. 

    That would easily do it.

    Presentation gets skipped by 90% of the users after watching it 5,6,7 times. So dont waste energy in that...

  • MasterB89's avatar
    MasterB89
    Seasoned Ace
    2 years ago
    @rick-rangerous Not sure what you mean about presentation is being skipped by 90% of the users. For a lot of the offline player base including myself.. we have been asking for "Full Presentation" to be re-added back to the game as for us its something we don't skip and is ultimately part of that "pure presentation". It is definitely something that should be added back into game with the same option to have "Full" or condensed like there was up to NHL 22.
  • NeonSkyline21's avatar
    NeonSkyline21
    Seasoned Ace
    2 years ago
    @MasterB89 I'd love for EA to give honest numbers showing the breakdown between this game's online and offline player base. Seeing which modes get which percentage of players would be really cool and would give context for their actions/non-actions in developing each year's title.
  • MasterB89's avatar
    MasterB89
    Seasoned Ace
    2 years ago

    @NeonSkyline21I'd love for that too. I know they have stated in these forums that the offline player base is lower and I'd guess it has diminished for the past 3 releases due to the lack of interest in those modes (the cause is the drop is EA NHL's own doing). I know mine has dropped from a game I'd play every day to a game I'll play once or twice a month. Even a lot of the GM sim content creators who used to do SIM franchises have either stopped or gone back to older games like NHL 14. Due to the newer games missing content, lack of presentation, glitches that span years, AI not being able to handle basic roster construction and line make ups. 

  • admiral745's avatar
    admiral745
    Seasoned Veteran
    2 years ago

    Love these ideas, all are necessary, especially banner raising ceremonies!

    I would also love if when you created a team, it did not end up doubling up player's that you move to that team, have that team be in the the player movement/player editor screen, where they actually are moved to that team in the rosters. Add in the ability to create their AHL affiliate team at the same time, so you can assign prospects to the team and still have them play for their CHL teams. 

  • ----Added/Extended from original list above----

    For my team to have more than just 3 Uniform options

    -I should be able to have a reverse retro

    -Heritage edition

    -Stadium Series Uni

    etc.etc

    Bring back Cancer and Camouflage Unis but this time WE get them,NOT just everyone else but us

    More Flexibility while creating our jerseys like the ability to spell out my City or Team name with letters,ala the NY Rangers

    Believe it or not a better color card or wheel cause it just seems there are certain colors that i have trouble accessing no matter how i mess with the wheel

    The message board Hockey Expert needs more dialogue\

    Press Conferences/Interviews

    (I have wayyyy more ideas still!)

    More Cellys

    -Blow kisses to the crowd

    -The Blade(From the Wesley Snipes Movie)

    -Suck it

    -Point all around to the stadium crowd 

    -No Sweat(Blow on fingernails then rub left or right upper chest)

    -Baseball Umpire(Calls OUT)

    -The Tebow

  • EA_Aljo's avatar
    EA_Aljo
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    2 years ago

    Hello, everyone. I moved this thread to the suggestions forum. Appreciate the feedback.

About NHL 24 General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and talk with us about your experiences in NHL 24.4,284 PostsLatest Activity: 2 years ago