Franchise Mode Trades

Product: NHL 21
Platform:Microsoft XBOX One
How often does the bug occur? Every time (100%)
Steps: How can we find the bug ourselves? Play Franchise Mode
What happens when the bug occurs? Players traded during the deadline stay on original team. Toews, Subban, etc were traded at the deadline but still remained on their teams.
What do you expect to see? Traded players on their new team.
Was the issue in online or offline mode? Offline
Insert Game Mode or Feature here Franchise
What time did you see the bug? (HH:MM AM/PM) This Weekend
What is your time zone? CST - GMT - 6:00
What is your gamertag/PSN ID? ThaTalent
PS4 Crash Reporting: Please copy the text you put in the crash report here. Na
EASHL issues? Please insert your Club Region. Na
What is your game language? English

‌

Trades executed during the deadline aren’t going through. Players remain on their same team. No cpu to cpu trades go through ever. Is this a known issue? Is there a fix? It’s been this way with 5 simmed franchises. 

I wish the majority of trades that happened at the deadline didn't go through as most of them are ridiculous. I have never had this happen to me, but there were a quite few posts of trades not going through before. I think they were usually trades involving users and not cpu to cpu though.

I've said it before, I'll say it again: they need to give us full control over our Franchise/Be A GM mode.
Allow us to force trades that the AI rejects, allow us to make CPU-CPU trades, allow us to veto trades the CPU makes. So many of the trades are so terrible and bone-headed; just have a pop-up for every trade and allow us to decide whether or not to let it happen, so we can reject some terrible trades. The AI will NEVER be good enough; that's fine. I can reconcile myself to that; I'm not going to rage at EA for not getting the AI to be smart enough to intelligently plan out a rebuild over a 2-3 season stretch. All they have to do is allow us to have oversight on our Be A GM mode so that we can help guide the other 30 teams in the league so that we can keep the game at least semi-realistic.

(Also, allow us to edit players FULLY - not just positions and roles and hair, but even ratings and potential and names/nationality/face, height/weight. Allow us to force retirements, or veto a retirement. Allow us to choose a personality type for players - at least our created players. Allow us to edit stats, even - I create a character to draft and play as in my Be A GM, and I want to give him the OHL stats that I got back in NHL 12 when I played 2 full junior seasons, not the underwhelming stats the game has him sim as. Also, I've had several players have their assists stolen from them for no reason, so I'd like to fix that. Not to mention the GWG problem.)

I mean, I saw the Avs let Landeskog walk, and I was surprised because I didn't think their cap situation was that bad. Burakovsky also left and was signed to some other team... which I could understand if he was overpaid (I'm a Caps fan; he's a very talented player but he's not consistent enough. I think his stats are at least partially a product of a perfect environment. If he's demanding $4-5M, let him walk, IMO.)
I looked at their cap space... they had $20M free cap room. Why'd they let Landeskog walk? That would NEVER happen. Imagine if you could just look through everybody's rosters at the end of the offseason but before anybody's played a preseason game; trade Landeskog and a 7th to the Avs for a 7th, then flip 7ths again so it's as if Landeskog never left in the 1st place.

It'd be time-consuming, but I'd be more than happy to go through all teams' rosters before the preseason to fix what needs to be fixed (and also see what teams improved, who they added), then again near the deadline to move a few pieces to free up cap space, help some rebuilding teams acquire picks and prospects, help a few contenders or fringe playoff teams get a boost... I'd be more than happy to put in the time if I could actually make moves for everybody and in return I'd get a Be A GM experience in which teams made smart moves and planned for the future, with bad teams rebuilding patiently and smartly, and good teams making shrewd moves to prepare for the playoffs.

Couldnt possibly agree with you more. 

Full  control. The whole point of franchise is to get the year over year experience. 

I spend a bunch of time on rosters too. I want to see vets move on to contending teams and others tank for draft picks and prospects. It’s fundamental. 

I only play offline. This really does ruin the game for me. Hope there is a fix 

By the way. All of those phantom trades that never went through happened on the new trade deadline mode. Terrible. 

I definitely want to see good teams look for that extra piece at the deadline, even if it’s an overpay and of course I like to see rebuilders sell off players for futures. The last few years of this series the deadline has been nothing and very few teams were actually making these types of trades.

However, as I’ve said many times here, the addition of the trade deadline and changing team states to seller, buyer, etc… ruins the mode for anybody that wants realism. There is absolutely no thought for past or future of teams or even team ratings. The top 3rd of the league (buyer status) all sell off any assets including their best prospects and multiple 1st round picks.  The bottom 3rd (seller status) sell off any and all players even if they are under contract for many years after and are cornerstones of the franchise. Even if these teams are having abnormal seasons such as a team like St. Louis missing the playoffs or Anaheim being first in the pacific.

Anaheim traded Drysdale (elite potential), two 1sts and two 2nds for rental players, while ST. Louis traded Schenn, Dunn, Krug, Perron and Binnington. Others traded were Barzal (NYI), Tkachuck (CGY), Miller (VAN) and Perfetti (WPG) just to name a few. Of course, the next year Anaheim was back to the basement and had no picks or their top prospect and the same thing happened to other teams at the next deadline.

@SkylerJames13 I am hopeful they tune down the number of trades made at the deadline, but I am definitely not expecting it to happen, especially this year. It wasn't great before, but much better. I think they would need to change the status of teams back to what it was before (champion, contender, hopeful, rebuilder) and possible add a setting for blockbuster trade frequency (low, med, high)

I learned a few years ago to save just before big events (draft, free agency) that way I can keep going back if I don’t like what happened during them. It takes a lot longer, especially this year with the deadline, but I can usually get it to make some sort of sense.

It's too bad that somebody involved in the mode isn't willing to come onto some of these forums and discuss why things work the way that they do in franchise mode. Its nice when the gameplay dev comes on and explains certain mechanics in the game, but with franchise mode we are always stuck wondering if things are working as intended or if they are bugs. I don't think this is a bug, but I would love to hear why certain features are as they are not only with the trade deadline, but there have been questions about coaching and scouting for years as well.

It would be cool to be able to give them feedback and discuss our improvement ideas too as they seem to have really smart, good ideas for the franchise that are just sometimes unclear why they are executed in such a way.