Forum Discussion

Anonymous's avatar
Anonymous
9 years ago
Approved

Characters balancing features

I was playing a bit and noticed that the game was a bit... unbalanced. So I "studied" each character and made a list of what they need.

NOTE: This is only for the playable characters, their abilities and upgrades, so don't expect to see a boss or a random weed on this list. If I think that a feature below is incorrect and need a small fix, it will be changed.

Classes/variants with (optional) means that they doesn't really need the change, I just think that it would be cool to have that

Peashooter class:

Commando Pea:

Increase accuracy

Increase rate of fire

Increase long range damage (6 => 7)

Increase middle range damage (9 => 10)

Increase short range damage (12 => 13)

Increase magazine capacity (30 => 35)

Agent Pea:

Increase zooming

Increase accuracy

Plasma Pea:

Decrease magazine capacity (14 => 12)

Increase ammo used on 2nd charge attack (1 => 2)

Increase ammo used on 3rd charge attack (1 => 3)

Increase 3rd charge damage (65 => 75)

Rock Pea (optional):

Increase health (150 => 175)

Enable Rock Shot to knock back enemies on direct hit

Sunflower class:

Sunflower:

Increase middle range damage (7 => 8)

Increase long range damage (6 => 7)

Mystic Flower

Decrease 2nd charge damage (50 => 35)

Decrease ammo used on 2nd charge attack (3 => 2)

Decrease ammo used on 3rd charge attack (6 => 3)

Shadow Flower:

Decrease middle range damage (8 => 7)

Decrease long range damage (7 => 6)

Increase rate of fire

Chomper class:

Chomper:

Increase damage (25 => 30)

Toxic Chomper:

Increase spray damage (6 => 8)

Power Chomper:

Decrease spray damage (10 => 8)

Armor Chomper:

Increase health (215 => 225)

Chomp Thing:

Increase damage (7 => 8)

Disco Chomper:

Decrease chomp damage (30 => 25)

Unicorn Chomper:

Enables armor penetration (optional)

Increase Rainbow Warp distance

Increase damage (25 => 30)

Cactus class:

Camo Cactus:

Increase close range damage (30 => 45)

Enables armor penetration

Kernel Corn class:

Kernel Corn:

Decrease magazine capacity (45 => 40 or 35)

BBQ Corn:

Increase magazine capacity (30 => 35) (optional)

Mob Cob:

Enables armor penetration

Decrease magazine capacity (45 => 40 or 35)

Party Corn

Party Time! should also increase reloading speed and rate of fire

Rose class:

All:

Increase weapon's homing distance and area

Rose:

Increase health (100 => 125)

Decrease damage (9 => 8)

Increase rate of fire

Decrease magazine capacity (30 => 25)

Druid Rose:

Increase health (100 => 125)

Give her a Toxic Aura

Frost Rose:

Decrease uncharged damage (7 => 5)

Decrease 2nd charge damage (33 => 20)

Decrease 3rd charge damage (50 => 40)

Enables insta-freeze (3rd charge only)

Completly remove speed penalty and enable jump while charging

Increase health (100 => 150)

Fire Rose:

Increase uncharged damage (5 => 7)

Increase 2nd charge damage (11 => 30)

Increase 3rd charge damage (50 => 75)

Decreased ammo used on 3rd charge attack (6 => 4)

Completly remove speed penalty and enable jump while charging

Increase magazine capacity (18 => 20)

Party Rose:

Increase health (100 => 125)

Increase rate of fire

Increase magazine capacity (18 => 25)

Disable Arcane Enigma to cancel Party Time!

Party Time! should also increase reloading speed and increase rate of fire

Nec'Rose:

Disables Scientists to "cure" debuffed zombies

Increase health (100 => 125)

Decrease charging rate

Increase ammo used on charged attack (4 => 5)

Citron class:

Electro Citron:

Decrease 2nd charge damage (50 =>35)

Frozen Citron:

Decrease damage (8 => 6)

Decrease the heat made by the weapon (optional)

Decrease overheat penalty (optional)

Iron Citron:

Enables armor penetration

Enables him to penetrate Z-Mech armor

Party Citron:

Party Time! should also decrease the weapon's heat and decrease overheat penalty

  

Torchwood class:

Increase long range damage (3 => 4)

Increase middle range damage (4 => 5)

Increase short range damage (5 => 6)

Foot Soldier class:

Camo Ranger

Enables armor penetration

Tank Commander:

Increase damage (60 => 75)

Increase splash damage (20 => 35 or 40)

Scuba Soldier:

Decrease close range damage (55=>30)

Increase splash radius

Enables the teammates to see the marked enemies

Enables him to swim (just kidding)

Engineer class:

All:

Add his beautiful facial hair from GW1 that was removed on GW2 ;-;

Painter:

Increase projectile speed

Increase firing rate (optional)

Plumber:
Increase splash radius

Sanitation Expert:

Re-adds his Toxic Aura

Scientist class:


Chemist:

Increase damage (35 => 40)

Archeologist:

Increase long range damage (8 => 12)

Increase zooming (optional)

Zoologist:

Decrease damage (30 => 25)

Increase magazine capacity (6 => 8)

Computer Scientist:

Disable Energy Warp to cancel Crunch Mode

Increase close range damage on Crunch Mode (70 => 80)

All-Star class:

Rugby Star (optional):

Decrease damage (8-24 => 6-15)

Increase splash radius

Goalie Star:

Decrease the heat made by the weapon (optional)

Decrease overheat penalty (optional)

Wrestling Star:

Increase damage (6-15 => 8-24)

Golf Star:

Increase zooming

Decrease health (200 => 175) (optional)

Decrease rate of fire

Tennis Star:
Decrease health (200 => 175) 

Super Brainz class:

Electro Brainz:

Enables all his punches to "share" electricity to the enemies

Cozmic Brainz:

Increase punches damage (20-45-70 => 25-50-75)

Party Brainz:

Party Time! should also decrease the laser overheating and increase rate of punching

Imp class:

All:

Upgrades will be also applied on Z-Mechs

Pylon Imp (optional):

Decrease damage (15-32 => 15-20)

Increase health (outside the Z-Mech) (75 => 100)

Increase Pylon-Mech resistance. The glass should also have a small resistance.

Roses and Iron-Citron should also not penetrate the Pylon Mech armor unlike other Z-Mechs

S.H.R.IMP:

Increase damage (5-6 => 6-7)

Fix a Water Cyclone glitch that cancels the ability when there is an enemy in front of the Mech

Party Imp:

Decrease magazine capacity (40 => 35)

Party Time! should also increase reloading speed and increase rate of fire

Scallywag Imp

Increase short range damage (20 => 30)

Increase Z-Mech long range damage (20-40 => 25-50)

Ol' pirate Captain Deadbeard class:

Captain Deadbeard:

Increase magazine capacity (12 => 14) (optional)

Increase close range damage (35 => 44)

Captain Cannon:
Increase magazine capacity (8 => 10)

Increase close range damage (20 => 60)

Captain Flameface:

Enables armor penetration

Increase magazine capacity (8 => 10)

Increase close range damage (25 => 30) (optional)

Captain Sharkbite:

Increase short range damage (16 => 18)

Captain Partyman:

Increase magazine capacity (8 => 12)

Increase short range damage (25-37 => 36-54)

Disable Barrel Blast to cancel Party Time!

Party Time! should also increase reloading speed and increase rate of fire

Hover-Goat 3000 class:

Increase running speed

Increase magazine capacity (30 => 35)

Stinky Goat:

Decrease damage (25 => 10)

Increase knockback

Increase running speed

Abilities:

Retro Gatling:

Increase damage (8-12 => 10-16)

OR

Increase resistance (66% => 75%)

Peel Shield:

Increase Peel Shield resistance (75 => 100)

Mega Awesome Laser:

Increase damage damage (10 => 12)

Upgrades:

Damage Upgrade: No changes required (I think)

Health Upgrade: Increase the health bonus (10 => 25)

Everything else: The upgrade should increase the specific stat by 25%

The armor penetration feature (Camo Cactus, Mob Cob, Camo Ranger, Captain Flameface and Unicorn Chomper) is to ignore armor. However, they cannot penetrate: Peel Shield and Z-Mechs.

Thank's for everyone who readed this.

Check out my 2 other posts:

Game ideas (closed)

Turf Takeover maps

143 Replies

  • Anonymous's avatar
    Anonymous
    9 years ago
    Approved

    @Boolerex has said some things about my post, I replied explaining some things and made some changes to the original post, but everything glitched and the post was deleted.

    So I "re-made" the post with some changes 🙂

  • Boolerex's avatar
    Boolerex
    9 years ago

    Rip my post.

    Still want explanation for sunflower damage nerf, rose bunch amount of change,engineer big bolt blaster nerf and pylon imp change as well as what you mean about armor penetration precisely.

  • Anonymous's avatar
    Anonymous
    9 years ago
    Approved

    @Boolerex

    Let's just hope that this don't glitch again.

    The health upgrade is now 25 only, because 10 is almost useless and 50 for certain characters is a lot.

    All the classes is because I tested, compared and had a opinion

    Sunflowers needs a small nerf is because they are a bit strong to the Scientists. Maybe because those stupid bots have no idea how powerful they are at short distance. But let's keep that.

    Rose is because she is weak compared to any playable class in the game. Not even against the Imp she could win. And loook, she can penetrate the Z-Mech armor right now. I was thinking on nerf 3 damage, but my friend says "all she needs is 5 damage buff and nothing else!". I think she is suposed to take the zombie from very far away with Homing Thistles (but not strong to make zombies suffer again. lol). But if Rose damage gets nerfed by 3 or more, he will never forgive me. And homing thistles with 8 damage is not a big deal I guess.

    Engineer BBB is because his damage is high compared to Pea Gatling ability. And 2-4 is not too much... is it?

    Pylon Imp because in the PvZ series, cones represents more health/resistance and not less health/resistance and more damage. I just want to make him follow the PvZ logic. Why? BECAUSE THIS IS FREAKIN PVZ!!! lol    And also, 5 damage nerf could make him a bit balanced. Will this make a confusion? Maybe.

    The Captain Sharkbite, from what you've told me, made me change my mind

    Cactus is because she is weak compared to the Pirates, so Buff the (actual) worst cactus! 25 damage is really too much, so increase only 10-15 instead. And I said increase magazine BY 5. Not TO 5. XD. So increase her the magazine capacity to have a total of 10. And before you ask, yes. I am referring Cactus as a she.

    The Unicorn Chomper is because he is hard to unlock, the only difference from him and the regular Chomper is the Rainbow Dash/Rainbow Warp/whatever it is called and because his unlocking method is connected to GW1. And in GW1, Chompers could penetrate armor, so allows Unicorn Chomper to penetrate armor

    And for the "Armor penetration" is to penetrate the spawnable zombies/weeds shields and armors (Coffin, Outhouse, Vase, Screen Door, Leaf shield...) It can also penetrate the barrel. In the case of the Z-Mech, it could also make sense, but when there is a Z-Mech on the map, the plants start shooting like crazy on the robot, making this tatic a bit overpowered with Mob Cob and Camo Cactus. And for the Peel Shild, this will not work, because the ability will become USELESS!

    And I have no idea about what to do to Legendary characters, because I don't have them. Party Rose is on this post because I thought she is a regular Rose with a vanquishing bar. But I'm not sure.

  • Boolerex's avatar
    Boolerex
    9 years ago
    @FelipeGames2000 wrote:

    The health upgrade is now 25 only, because 10 is almost useless and 50 for certain characters is a lot.

    As it stand right now, hp upgrade is a near-mandatory pick for 75 hp class , decent for 100 hp class, situational for 125-150 hp class and useless for anything higher. Which is why I think hp upgrade should be a 10% increase. a flat +25 hp would be way too good for imp.

    @FelipeGames2000 wrote:

    All the classes is because I tested, compared and had a opinion

    Sunflowers needs a small nerf is because they are a bit strong to the Scientists. Maybe because those stupid bots have no idea how powerful they are at short distance. But let's keep that.

    Bot are bot, Imp bot is by far the worst bot because he don't know how to call Z-mech and make no attempt at dodging stuff. despite being one of the best zombie right now. Scientist bot got the same problem too,as he make no attempt to get in close range then in the offensive. Plz don't use AI match as a argument.

    @FelipeGames2000 wrote:

    Rose is because she is weak compared to any playable class in the game. Not even against the Imp she could win. And loook, she can penetrate the Z-Mech armor right now. I was thinking on nerf 3 damage, but my friend says "all she needs is 5 damage buff and nothing else!". I think she is suposed to take the zombie from very far away with Homing Thistles (but not strong to make zombies suffer again. lol). But if Rose damage gets nerfed by 3 or more, he will never forgive me. And homing thistles with 8 damage is not a big deal I guess.

    A rose can easily win against a imp expect if she get gravity grenade'd. Which is more a problem with gravity grenade being too strong then anything. Time snare and goatify make a imp very vulnerable,while arcane enigma is a good options to start or end a fight against him. And of course homing shot. And that not the only thing rose can deal with alone.

    Her projectile don't have homing at long range and are slow as hell. it clearly not meant to be used at long range even with the lack of damage dropoff.idk what you thought here.

    The last thing she need is a damage nerf,even with a fire rate buff,considering rose didn't have a great DPS at the first place.

    @FelipeGames2000 wrote:

    Engineer BBB is because his damage is high compared to Pea Gatling ability. And 2-4 is not too much... is it?

    Engi BBB shot slightly slower compared to Pea Gatling,so they kinda end up having the same DPS. a 2-4 damage nerf is still quite alots as it got a fast fire rate,I could get a -1 damage nerf across the board due to the other avantage BBB have over pea gatling, but a bigger nerf then that would be a tad too much.

    @FelipeGames2000 wrote:

    Pylon Imp because in the PvZ series, cones represents more health/resistance and not less health/resistance and more damage. I just want to make him follow the PvZ logic. Why? BECAUSE THIS IS FREAKIN PVZ!!! lol    And also, 5 damage nerf could make him a bit balanced. Will this make a confusion? Maybe.

    Plz plz. pylon imp gimmick is to have bunch of splash damage right now,let's not unnecessary add more hp because of a pylon hat hue.

    @FelipeGames2000 wrote:

    Cactus is because she is weak compared to the Pirates, so Buff the (actual) worst cactus! 25 damage is really too much, so increase only 10-15 instead. And I said increase magazine BY 5. Not TO 5. XD. So increase her the magazine capacity to have a total of 10. And before you ask, yes. I am referring Cactus as a she.

    A magazine size of 10 would be a bit too much again here. But I could get the reload speed.

    @FelipeGames2000 wrote:

    The Unicorn Chomper is because he is hard to unlock, the only difference from him and the regular Chomper is the Rainbow Dash/Rainbow Warp/whatever it is called and because his unlocking method is connected to GW1. And in GW1, Chompers could penetrate armor, so allows Unicorn Chomper to penetrate armor

    Heh it kinda a unnecessary buff again.

    @FelipeGames2000 wrote:

    And for the "Armor penetration" is to penetrate the spawnable zombies/weeds shields and armors (Coffin, Outhouse, Vase, Screen Door, Leaf shield...) It can also penetrate the barrel. In the case of the Z-Mech, it could also make sense, but when there is a Z-Mech on the map, the plants start shooting like crazy on the robot, making this tatic a bit overpowered with Mob Cob and Camo Cactus. And for the Peel Shild, this will not work, because the ability will become USELESS!

    So armor penetration = something to counter barrel...That kinda nothing hue.

  • Anonymous's avatar
    Anonymous
    9 years ago
    Approved

    @Boolerex

    The bot part is only to study the character. But now that you told me, Sunflower is fine right now. And she is the only character that I wanted to nerf because in bots war, Sunflower won twice. The rest is because I played and I really know of what they need. I promise you that I will not change a character only because he sucks as a bot.

    I tested (not with bots) Rose vs Imp, and Imps have better surviving chances. All they need is a gravity grenade and their gun. Rose can goatfy? Just normaly run. Rose have Time snare? I still can shoot (Gravity grenade also can shoot, but it is better). Arcane Enigma? Just wait until she is over. And also, she is weak compared to her zombie version, Engineer, with the BBB and Sonic Grenades. Remember that sonic grenades fully paralise you. But in case Popcap abuse with the homing buff, I guess the damage can be better with -2.

    Big Bolt Blaster is really strong compared to Pea Gatling. The firing speed is the same, the ammo is the same, but BBB has massive damage compared to PG.

    Pylon Imp is (like I said) because Cones in PvZ logic is more resistance. And will this make sense? A PvZ game without the PvZ logic? He don't need any buffs or nerfs, I just want to see how people react to this opinion.

    Camo Cactus, is... well... you at least agree with me. but popcap can chose. 10 ammo or faster reaload.

    Unicorn Chomper: as I already said, connection with GW1, GW1 Chomper penetrate armor and the teleport is the only difference. This buff is kinda optional to people who aren't satisfied with the teleport and aren't used to a Chomper without armor penetration.

    "So armor penetration = something to counter barrel...That kinda nothing hue." AND to kill those irritating armored zombies and weeds easier. Nothing else.

  • Anonymous's avatar
    Anonymous
    9 years ago
    Approved

    @Boolerex

    So... I just tested Pea Gatling and Big Bolt Blaster and they deal the exact same damage. So I removed BBB nerf. :D

  • Anonymous's avatar
    Anonymous
    9 years ago
    Approved

    Small changes:

    I unlocked party rose and citron. Citron is fine. Rose needs some buffs. here are the changes:

    Added Party Rose statics

    Removed Herobrine (just kidding)

    Added a small Imp buff

  • Boolerex's avatar
    Boolerex
    9 years ago
    @FelipeGames2000 wrote:

    @maxandmike27

    Why not?

    Because BBQ corn is already one of the best variant in the game and definably don't need a buff? His not great ammo count is his only weakness right now.

Featured Places

Recent Discussions