i think this is a record, there is a 20m GP difference between My guild and our opponents. This is by far ridiculous. We have fought guilds up to 10m Stronger but this is utterly unfair and needs fixing. And before anyone says its based on registered GP. its 50 in each guild registered. Has anyone else had similar issues?

If you both have 50m participating, what's the problem here?

"Viserys;c-1420170" wrote:If you both have 50m participating, what's the problem here?Because a GP difference of 20m is massive advantage to the other guild. 5-10 fair enough nothing is going to be perfect but 20m GP, there is clearly a problem with the matchmaking in this mode

Matching is determined by the "participating" guild power, not how much the guild has total. So you "should" be fine in this one. Good luck.

It doesn't take total gp into account. Only the toons that have 6k+ gp. If they have everyone at level 53 g7 for TB gp most of those toons will not qualify for TW.

"Zaraos;c-1420172" wrote:"Viserys;c-1420170" wrote:If you both have 50m participating, what's the problem here?Because a GP difference of 20m is massive advantage to the other guild. 5-10 fair enough nothing is going to be perfect but 20m GP, there is clearly a problem with the matchmaking in this modeBut it's not, because if you both have the same registered GP, they don't have 20m more power than you that they can use.

20m Difference between Guilds matched in TW

Sargana
7 years ago
If you both have 50m participating, what's the problem here?
Zaraos
New Spectator
7 years ago
"Viserys;c-1420170" wrote:
If you both have 50m participating, what's the problem here?

Because a GP difference of 20m is massive advantage to the other guild. 5-10 fair enough nothing is going to be perfect but 20m GP, there is clearly a problem with the matchmaking in this mode
Whatelse73
Rising Veteran
7 years ago
Matching is determined by the "participating" guild power, not how much the guild has total. So you "should" be fine in this one. Good luck.
ryl88
7 years ago
It doesn't take total gp into account. Only the toons that have 6k+ gp. If they have everyone at level 53 g7 for TB gp most of those toons will not qualify for TW.
Sargana
7 years ago
"Zaraos;c-1420172" wrote:
"Viserys;c-1420170" wrote:
If you both have 50m participating, what's the problem here?

Because a GP difference of 20m is massive advantage to the other guild. 5-10 fair enough nothing is going to be perfect but 20m GP, there is clearly a problem with the matchmaking in this mode

But it's not, because if you both have the same registered GP, they don't have 20m more power than you that they can use.
TheChampionBum
7 years ago
They are saying that both guilds have 100% participation and the differences between the guilds are 20 million GP. That is a problem. HOWEVER, how can you even know how many participants the other guild even has? As far as I know, there is no way to know that.
Zaraos
New Spectator
7 years ago
"TheChampionBum;c-1420179" wrote:
They are saying that both guilds have 100% participation and the differences between the guilds are 20 million GP. That is a problem. HOWEVER, how can you even know how many participants the other guild even has? As far as I know, there is no way to know that.

For each person not registered sectors lose a peaceable team for 50 members on each side you can place 25 teams on each sector. If they have 49 registered in one guild you can place 24 teams in each sector and so on. But yeah our sectors are 25 so everyone is registered
emvedebe
7 years ago
"Zaraos;c-1420194" wrote:
"TheChampionBum;c-1420179" wrote:
They are saying that both guilds have 100% participation and the differences between the guilds are 20 million GP. That is a problem. HOWEVER, how can you even know how many participants the other guild even has? As far as I know, there is no way to know that.

For each person not registered sectors lose a peaceable team for 50 members on each side you can place 25 teams on each sector. If they have 49 registered in one guild you can place 24 teams in each sector and so on. But yeah our sectors are 25 so everyone is registered

with 49 vs 50 you still have 25 slots.
Hypothetically, even if a 3mil player of theirs didn't sign up you're still facing a 17m GP difference, wich i would consider a mismatch.
DarthPedal
7 years ago
The system is broken, thats a fact. We also faced 17mil more than us, and 50 Vs 50 participants. So its a problem that CG have to look into.
emvedebe
7 years ago
"Viserys;c-1420205" wrote:
"Zaraos;c-1420194" wrote:
"TheChampionBum;c-1420179" wrote:
They are saying that both guilds have 100% participation and the differences between the guilds are 20 million GP. That is a problem. HOWEVER, how can you even know how many participants the other guild even has? As far as I know, there is no way to know that.

For each person not registered sectors lose a peaceable team for 50 members on each side you can place 25 teams on each sector. If they have 49 registered in one guild you can place 24 teams in each sector and so on. But yeah our sectors are 25 so everyone is registered

It's possible that the team setup is based on the larger of the two guilds, and not the smaller. In which case it could be 50 v 46 and you'd still be placing 25 teams.

I don't have enough info to know whether the team values are based on the larger, smaller, or average count between the two guilds since the game doesn't readily expose that. Maybe some of the coordinators in the largest guilds would know the answer to this.

Nah, it's based on the smaller guild. 49/50 = 25, 47/48 = 24, 45/46 = 23.