These kinds of conversations are fun but very subjective of course. However I feel you can make an objective case for Andor being a good show. Here’s my 5 point case:
1. The concept - showing the Star Wars universe principally from the perspective of the lives of ordinary people - was a good one that carried through well
2. The acting - consistently good with some really stand out performances
3. The plot - despite Cassian’s plot armour (unavoidable) there was sufficient challenge and jeopardy to present a series of engaging stories
4. The moral ambiguity- unlike most SW offerings, Andor did more to blur the lines between dark and light - giving sympathetic moments to imperial officers or presenting terrorism as a ‘good’ action in response to oppression- and giving its protagonists more morally complex motivations- it was a grown up show in that respect
5. Stand out moments that didn’t rely on CGI - the production was properly dramatic and not just a cartoon being levered into a live action context
Now - you don’t have to like any of that and it’s great if you prefer Mandalorian or Bad Batch - but to say it’s not good is just inaccurate.