This has been a issue from the start of guilds. Too many of the numbers are dependant on when the guild leader last logged in, the guild reset time, and the last time the member logged in. But anytime someone complains you get responses that say its fine if you check at this time or do a guild wipe or some other set of hurdles. The point is the counters should work period, independant of a dozen login factors. And you should not have to do a guild reset or other "simple" hurdles to get it to work. I basically just check the lifetime contributions and gauge against how long they have been in the guild. If they arent doing at least half (300) then they arent pulling their weight. I also have a 2 day inactivity rule. Between the two we keep a pretty active roster of 40 to 45 members. Im hoping they give the guild manage section some love soon.
